Surprise Bill From a Surgeon at an In-Network Hospital
What can I do about a surprise bill from a surgeon?
A bill from an out-of-network surgeon, assistant surgeon, or anesthesiologist for non-emergency care at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical center may be limited by the No Surprises Act. For many private plans, you should not owe more than in-network cost sharing for a covered service unless a valid notice and consent applies. An anesthesiologist or an assistant surgeon cannot use that consent to waive the protection. This page explains how to check the bill and how to dispute it. It does not promise the bill will be removed.
Get help with my bill →When does the No Surprises Act limit a surgeon's bill?
CMS says that, beginning January 2022, for people who get coverage through an employer, including a federal, state, or local government employer, through the Health Insurance Marketplace, or directly through an individual health plan, the rules ban balance billing and out-of-network cost sharing for emergency services and for certain non-emergency services. In those situations, your cost cannot be higher than if an in-network provider had furnished the service, and any coinsurance or deductible must be based on in-network rates. CMS also says the rules ban out-of-network charges and balance billing for ancillary care, such as an anesthesiologist or an assistant surgeon, by an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility, and ban certain other out-of-network charges without advance notice.
For non-emergency care, 45 CFR 149.420 says a nonparticipating provider who furnishes an item or service, other than emergency services, for which the plan provides benefits, at a participating health care facility, must not bill you, or hold you liable, for more than the plan's cost-sharing amount for that item or service, unless the notice-and-consent criteria are met. 45 CFR 149.120 is the matching rule for the plan: when it applies, the plan must not impose cost sharing greater than the participating-provider amount, and it must count that cost sharing toward in-network deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums. The section applies for plan years, and in the individual market for policy years, beginning on or after January 1, 2022.
45 CFR 149.30 says a health care facility, for non-emergency services, is a hospital, a hospital outpatient department, a critical access hospital, or an ambulatory surgical center. CMS's consumer page describes the non-emergency protection as care related to a visit to an in-network hospital, hospital outpatient department, or ambulatory surgical center. A bill from a surgeon at an out-of-network hospital, or at an ordinary office that is not one of those facilities, is not this protection. Emergency care uses a different section, so see an emergency room bill the plan did not cover and the No Surprises Act.
CMS says these rules do not apply to people with coverage through Medicare, Medicaid, Indian Health Services, Veterans Affairs health care, or TRICARE, because those programs have other protections. If you have one of those programs, use that program's appeal. Do not send a Medicare Summary Notice to the No Surprises complaint process as if it were a private-plan bill. If the denial is for cataract surgery rather than an out-of-network surgeon's bill, see a cataract surgery denial.
References: CMS: What the No Surprises Act protects, and which programs are outside it · CMS: No Surprises Act help for consumers · 45 CFR 149.420, Balance billing for non-emergency care at an in-network facility, including anesthesia · 45 CFR 149.120: Out-of-network care at an in-network facility · 45 CFR 149.30, Surprise billing definitions, including air ambulance service
Which providers cannot ask you to waive the protection?
45 CFR 149.420(b) says the notice-and-consent exception does not apply to ancillary services. The regulation defines ancillary services to include items and services related to emergency medicine, anesthesiology, pathology, radiology, and neonatology, whether a physician or a non-physician practitioner provides them. It also includes items and services provided by assistant surgeons, hospitalists, and intensivists. It includes diagnostic services, including radiology and laboratory services. It also includes items and services from a nonparticipating provider if there is no participating provider at that facility who can furnish the item or service. A form you signed does not waive the limit for those ancillary services.
The same subsection says notice and consent also do not apply to items or services furnished because of unforeseen, urgent medical needs that arise at the time the item or service is furnished, even if the provider had satisfied notice and consent for something else. An anesthesiologist and an assistant surgeon are in the ancillary list. They cannot ask you to waive this protection for that ancillary care. CMS states the same ban for ancillary care such as an anesthesiologist or an assistant surgeon at an in-network facility. How an anesthesia bill fits that rule is in an anesthesia bill the plan did not cover. A separate professional bill and a facility bill can both be real, so see two bills for one hospital visit and a bill from a doctor you never saw.
References: 45 CFR 149.420, Balance billing for non-emergency care at an in-network facility, including anesthesia · CMS: What the No Surprises Act protects, and which programs are outside it
When can notice and consent apply to a surgeon?
The operating surgeon is not named in the ancillary list the way an assistant surgeon and an anesthesiologist are. 45 CFR 149.420(c) allows notice and consent for a nonparticipating provider's non-ancillary items and services, unless state law prohibits it. If no participating surgeon at that facility can furnish the service, the out-of-network surgeon is ancillary under paragraph (b)(1)(iv), and notice and consent do not apply. If the care became urgent and unforeseen at the time it was furnished, notice and consent do not apply to that care either.
When notice and consent are allowed, the regulation requires a written notice, on paper or electronically as you select, that is physically separate from other documents and not attached to or incorporated into any other document. If the appointment is scheduled at least 72 hours before the service, the notice must be given no later than 72 hours before the service. If the appointment is scheduled inside that 72 hours, the notice must be given on the date the appointment is scheduled. If you are given the notice on the same day as the service, it must be given no later than 3 hours before the service. The notice must say the provider is out of network, give a good faith estimate, say that prior authorization or other care-management limits may apply, and say that consent is optional and that you may seek care from an available in-network provider, in which case your cost sharing would not exceed the in-network amount.
The consent must be voluntary, without undue influence, fraud, or duress, and it must be on the form specified in HHS guidance. It must acknowledge that what you pay might not count toward an in-network deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. You may revoke it in writing before you receive the items and services. An authorized representative under state law may sign, but that person cannot be a provider affiliated with the facility or an employee of the facility unless the person is your family member. The provider must give you a copy of the signed notice and consent in person, by mail, or by email, as you choose. The notice and consent must be available in any of the 15 most common languages in the state, or in a region that reasonably reflects the area the facility serves. If your preferred language is not among those and you cannot understand the language used, the criteria are not met unless the provider gets a qualified interpreter. A general hospital registration form is not, by itself, this notice. Ask for the separate notice and consent the provider says you signed.
The consent is consent to receive the information. 45 CFR 149.420(g) says it is not a contract that binds you to the estimated charge or to be treated by that provider. The facility, or the provider if the facility did not keep it, must retain the signed notice and consent for at least 7 years. How to read a form the provider calls a waiver is also in a balance billing dispute.
References: 45 CFR 149.420, Balance billing for non-emergency care at an in-network facility, including anesthesia
How do I dispute the bill?
Match the surgeon's bill, the assistant's bill, and the anesthesiologist's bill to the explanation of benefits for that same claim before you pay. The amount the plan says you owe is the place to start. If the explanation of benefits uses out-of-network cost sharing for a covered service at an in-network facility, ask the plan whether 45 CFR 149.120 and 45 CFR 149.420 apply, and ask for a corrected explanation if they do. Ask the provider, in writing, to limit the bill to the in-network cost sharing and to refund any amount you paid above it. Name the facility, the date, the clinician, and the amount. Keep copies.
CMS's No Surprises Help Desk can answer questions about whether the law applies and can help you submit a complaint. The get-help page on cms.gov says to call 1-800-985-3059. It says the desk is available 7 days a week, on weekdays from 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Eastern Time, and on weekends from 10:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. Eastern Time. It says help is available in Spanish, French, Arabic, Russian, Nepali, and over 350 other languages. The same page says the desk can answer questions about the No Surprises Act, help you submit a complaint against a provider or facility, and direct you to other resources if your situation is not covered. It says the desk cannot act as legal counsel, give medical advice, or offer financial assistance. The consumer page at cms.gov/nosurprises/consumers also lists 1-800-985-3059. You can submit a complaint by phone or through the complaint form CMS links from that help page.
A private plan's own appeal is separate from the complaint. If the plan denied the underlying service, use the appeal on the denial. That appeal is in how to appeal a health insurance denial. The broader out-of-network review is in an out-of-network medical bill. If the denied service was a knee replacement, see a knee replacement denial. If the denial is for a septoplasty rather than an out-of-network surgeon's bill, see a septoplasty denial.
References: CMS: No Surprises Help Desk, 1-800-985-3059 · CMS: No Surprises Act help for consumers · 45 CFR 149.120: Out-of-network care at an in-network facility · 45 CFR 149.420, Balance billing for non-emergency care at an in-network facility, including anesthesia · CMS: Your medical bill rights when using insurance
Do state laws change this?
State law can change the notice-and-consent path. 45 CFR 149.420(c) says the provider satisfies notice and consent only when the criteria are met and state law does not prohibit that exception. A state may also give you a protection this federal section does not. This page does not list state statutes, because they are not the same in every state. Ask the No Surprises Help Desk which agency handles your plan, and ask your state insurance department whether a state rule also applies. Do not assume another state's statute applies to your bill.
References: 45 CFR 149.420, Balance billing for non-emergency care at an in-network facility, including anesthesia · CMS: No Surprises Help Desk, 1-800-985-3059
What this page cannot promise
This is general information, not legal advice. The protection described here is for the plans and the settings the rules name. A valid notice and consent, where it is allowed, can leave you with an out-of-network bill from a non-ancillary surgeon. A complaint or an appeal can leave the bill in place. Nothing on this page promises that a surgeon's charge will be removed or that a plan will pay a service it does not cover.
Sources and further help
These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.
- 45 CFR 149.420, Balance billing for non-emergency care at an in-network facility, including anesthesia ↗
- 45 CFR 149.120: Out-of-network care at an in-network facility ↗
- 45 CFR 149.30, Surprise billing definitions, including air ambulance service ↗
- CMS: What the No Surprises Act protects, and which programs are outside it ↗
- CMS: No Surprises Act help for consumers ↗
- CMS: No Surprises Help Desk, 1-800-985-3059 ↗
- CMS: Your medical bill rights when using insurance ↗
Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.