Cataract Surgery Denied by Insurance
Can insurance deny cataract surgery?
Yes. A plan can deny cataract surgery. Medicare.gov says Part B may cover cataract surgery that implants conventional intraocular lenses, depending on where you live. That sentence is not a promise of payment. When the surgery is covered, Medicare.gov says you pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after the Part B deductible. A bill for a premium lens upgrade is a different question from a denial of the cataract removal. This page explains both. It does not promise that Medicare or a plan will pay.
Get help with my bill →What does Medicare cover for cataract surgery?
These Medicare points were checked on Medicare.gov and on CMS's November 16, 2012 guidance on cataract lens charges on November 17, 2026. Medicare.gov says Part B may cover cataract surgery that implants conventional intraocular lenses, depending on where you live. Medicare.gov describes cataract surgery as removing a cloudy natural lens and, in most cases, replacing it with a clear artificial lens. The page does not list which local differences the phrase "depending on where you live" refers to. Use the denial or the Medicare Summary Notice for the rule that was applied to your claim.
When the surgery is covered, Medicare.gov states the cost share. For covered cataract surgery in a hospital outpatient setting or an ambulatory surgical center, after you meet the Part B deductible, you pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount to both the facility and the doctor who performs the surgery. For covered cataract surgery in a doctor's office, after you meet the Part B deductible, you pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount for both the intraocular lens and the surgery to implant it. Medicare.gov also says it does not usually cover eyeglasses or contact lenses, but Part B covers one pair of eyeglasses with standard frames, or one set of contact lenses, after each cataract surgery that implants an intraocular lens.
CMS's November 16, 2012 guidance says Medicare coverage and payment for cataract surgery are the same whether the surgery uses conventional surgical technique or a bladeless, computer-controlled laser. Under either method, the guidance says Medicare will cover and pay for the cataract removal and insertion of a conventional intraocular lens. That sentence is about the technique. It does not say every cataract surgery is medically necessary. A denial that says the surgery was not reasonable and necessary is still a denial you can appeal. The general surgery appeal is in surgery denied by insurance.
References: Medicare.gov: Cataract surgery · CMS (November 16, 2012): Laser-assisted cataract surgery and CMS Rulings 05-01 and 1536-R
What if I was billed for a premium lens?
A premium lens charge is not the same thing as a denial of the cataract removal. CMS's November 16, 2012 guidance explains two rulings. CMS Ruling 05-01, issued May 3, 2005, allows a beneficiary to pay additional charges, which Medicare does not cover because they are not part of a Medicare benefit category, for insertion of a presbyopia-correcting intraocular lens after cataract surgery. CMS Ruling 1536-R, effective for services on and after January 22, 2007, allows the same kind of additional charge for an astigmatism-correcting intraocular lens.
The guidance says those additional charges are limited to two categories. One is the portion of the facility or physician charge for the presbyopia-correcting or astigmatism-correcting lens that exceeds the charge for insertion of a conventional lens. The other is facility or physician charges for resources required for fitting and vision acuity testing of that lens that exceed the resources furnished for a conventional lens. The guidance says services that are part of cataract surgery with a conventional lens, including the incision by whatever method, capsulotomy by whatever method, and lens fragmentation by whatever method, may not be charged to the patient. The beneficiary may be charged only for the non-covered services the rulings specify. Ask the office for an itemized bill that separates the conventional surgery from the premium-lens amount. If a line charges you for a covered step of the cataract removal because a laser was used, that is the charge the guidance says may not be billed to you.
A private plan uses its own written policy for cataract surgery and for a premium lens. This page does not state a visual-acuity number, because a number, when a plan uses one, is in that policy. Ask for the policy. Do not treat Medicare's conventional-lens rule as a private plan's premium-lens rule, and do not treat one plan's acuity line as a national rule.
References: CMS (November 16, 2012): Laser-assisted cataract surgery and CMS Rulings 05-01 and 1536-R · U.S. Department of Labor: Filing a claim for your health benefits
What if a Medicare Advantage plan denied the surgery?
42 CFR 422.101(b) says a Medicare Advantage organization must follow CMS national coverage determinations, general coverage and benefit conditions in traditional Medicare, and written local coverage decisions for the area. 42 CFR 422.101(c) says the organization must base medical necessity determinations on those coverage criteria. It may not deny a basic benefit based on criteria outside that section. 42 CFR 422.138 says that when a coordinated care plan uses prior authorization, it may use that process only to confirm the diagnoses or other medical criteria that support coverage, to make sure a basic benefit is medically necessary under 42 CFR 422.101(c)(1), or to make sure a supplemental benefit is clinically appropriate. If the plan approved the surgery through prior authorization, or through a pre-service or concurrent decision, it may not later deny coverage for lack of medical necessity, and it may not reopen that decision, except for good cause or if there is reliable evidence of fraud or similar fault.
HealthCare.gov says preauthorization is a decision that a service is medically necessary, and that it is not a promise of payment. That definition is for the plans HealthCare.gov describes. A Medicare Advantage denial uses the Medicare notice. The plan's appeal is in how to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial. If the notice says approval was missing, see a prior authorization denial.
References: 42 CFR 422.101: Medicare Advantage basic benefits, including traditional Medicare coverage criteria · 42 CFR 422.138: Medicare Advantage prior authorization · HealthCare.gov: Preauthorization
How do I appeal a cataract surgery denial?
Use the notice. Ask the ophthalmologist for a letter of medical necessity and the records the policy asks for. The letter should answer the reason on the denial. A letter that only says you have a cataract does not answer a specific criterion. If the notice says the surgery is not medically necessary, see a medical necessity denial. If the only dispute is the premium-lens amount described above, ask the office to separate that amount before you appeal the cataract removal as if it had been denied.
For a private plan, 29 CFR 2560.503-1 gives a group health plan at least 180 days after you receive the denial to appeal, and 45 CFR 147.136 applies that standard to non-grandfathered group and individual coverage. HealthCare.gov says to file within 180 days, and to request an external review in writing within 4 months when the dispute is a medical judgment. If the notice gives a later date, use the notice. For a private-sector workplace health plan, the Department of Labor says an urgent appeal must be decided as soon as your medical needs require, and no later than 72 hours after the plan receives the appeal. Cataract surgery is not automatically that urgent appeal. Ask the ophthalmologist, and use the process on the notice. The steps are in how to appeal a health insurance denial and how to request an external review.
For Original Medicare, 42 CFR 405.942 says a redetermination must be filed within 120 calendar days after you receive the notice. Receipt is presumed five calendar days after the date on the notice unless there is evidence otherwise. The steps are in how to appeal an Original Medicare denial. A clinician's call does not move the deadline unless the notice says it does. A separate anesthesia bill is a different problem. See an anesthesia bill insurance did not cover.
References: 29 CFR 2560.503-1: Claims procedure, including the 180-day appeal period · 45 CFR 147.136: Internal claims, appeals, and external review · HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · HealthCare.gov: External review · U.S. Department of Labor: Filing a claim for your health benefits · 42 CFR 405.942: Original Medicare redetermination filing deadline · Medicare.gov: Appeals in Original Medicare
What this page cannot promise
This is general information, not medical or legal advice. Medicare.gov says Part B may cover cataract surgery that implants a conventional lens, depending on where you live. A plan can deny a request. A presbyopia-correcting or astigmatism-correcting lens feature is a non-covered charge under the CMS rulings, when the charge is limited to the amounts those rulings allow. An appeal can leave a denial in place. Nothing on this page promises that Medicare or a plan will approve cataract surgery or remove a premium-lens charge.
Sources and further help
These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.
- HealthCare.gov: Preauthorization ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals ↗
- HealthCare.gov: External review ↗
- U.S. Department of Labor: Filing a claim for your health benefits ↗
- 29 CFR 2560.503-1: Claims procedure, including the 180-day appeal period ↗
- 45 CFR 147.136: Internal claims, appeals, and external review ↗
- Medicare.gov: Cataract surgery ↗
- CMS (November 16, 2012): Laser-assisted cataract surgery and CMS Rulings 05-01 and 1536-R ↗
- 42 CFR 422.101: Medicare Advantage basic benefits, including traditional Medicare coverage criteria ↗
- 42 CFR 422.138: Medicare Advantage prior authorization ↗
- 42 CFR 405.942: Original Medicare redetermination filing deadline ↗
- Medicare.gov: Appeals in Original Medicare ↗
Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.