Skip to content
BillHelp
Menu
YOUR BILLHELP GUIDE

Knee Replacement Denied by Insurance

What can I do if insurance denies a knee replacement?

A plan can deny a knee replacement or other knee surgery for a missing approval, a medical-necessity decision, or a conservative-care rule in its own policy. For Original Medicare, total knee arthroplasty can be paid as an inpatient procedure or an outpatient procedure. Removing it from the inpatient-only list in 2018 did not mean every surgery must be outpatient, and it did not remove the two-midnight rule. A Medicare Advantage plan has to follow Original Medicare coverage rules when it decides a basic benefit. This page explains the denial and the appeal. It does not promise payment.

Get help with my bill →
General U.S. guidance. Your plan documents and denial notice explain the process that applies to your case. Medicare, Medicaid, and other programs may use different rules. This is not medical or legal advice, and no result is guaranteed.

What should I read on a knee surgery denial?

Read the denial for the procedure, the date, and the reason. A missing prior authorization, a finding that the surgery is not medically necessary, and a disagreement about whether the hospital stay is inpatient or outpatient are different disputes. HealthCare.gov says a plan may require preauthorization before a service, except in an emergency, and that preauthorization is not a promise of payment. If the notice says approval was missing, see a prior authorization denial. If it says the surgery is not medically necessary, see a medical necessity denial. The general surgery appeal is in a surgery denial.

Ask whether the denied code is a total knee arthroplasty. CMS's Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement frequently asked questions name CPT code 27447 for that procedure. Match the code on the denial to the code your surgeon says was requested. Do not ask anyone to change an accurate code. If the denial is for a septoplasty rather than a knee replacement, see a septoplasty denial.

References: HealthCare.gov: Preauthorization · CMS: Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement frequently asked questions, total knee arthroplasty

What does a conservative-care requirement mean?

A private plan's written medical policy may require documented conservative care, such as medication or physical therapy, before it approves knee surgery. That requirement is the plan's policy. This page does not state a number of weeks or visits, because a number, when a plan uses one, is in that policy and is not a federal rule. Ask for the policy. The Department of Labor says that when a group health plan denies a claim for medical necessity, the notice must explain the scientific or clinical judgment for your case, or state that the explanation will be provided free on request. 29 CFR 2560.503-1 says the plan must provide the relevant documents free of charge on request, including a statement of policy about the denied treatment. How to ask is in medical records and the claim file.

If the plan says you must complete physical therapy first, the therapy denial is a separate question. See physical therapy visits denied by insurance. Do not ask a therapist to record visits that did not happen. Your clinician can respond to the criterion the policy actually states.

References: U.S. Department of Labor: Filing a claim for your health benefits · 29 CFR 2560.503-1: Claims procedure, including the 180-day appeal period

What did Medicare change about knee replacement in 2018?

CMS's fact sheet for the calendar year 2018 hospital outpatient payment rule says the inpatient-only list includes procedures that are typically only provided in the inpatient setting and therefore are not paid under the outpatient payment system. For 2018, CMS removed total knee arthroplasty from that list. CMS's joint-replacement frequently asked questions say CPT code 27447 was removed in the calendar year 2018 final rule dated December 14, 2017. The same answer says Medicare will pay for the procedure in the outpatient setting, and that CMS does not expect every total knee arthroplasty for a Medicare beneficiary to be done outpatient.

The two-midnight rule still applies. CMS's joint-replacement questions say the rule applies to total knee arthroplasty at any acute care hospital. CMS's two-midnight fact sheet says an inpatient admission is generally payable under Part A when the admitting practitioner expects the patient to need a hospital stay that crosses two midnights and the medical record supports that expectation. For a stay expected to last less than two midnights, when the procedure is not on the inpatient-only list, the fact sheet says an inpatient admission may still be payable under Part A on a case-by-case basis, based on the admitting physician's judgment, if the record supports that an inpatient admission is necessary. CMS's provider page on hip and knee replacement says patients can receive total knee arthroplasty as an inpatient or as an outpatient if the criteria are met, and that this does not change the two-midnight rule. A local coverage policy can describe what the record in that area should contain. Ask which written policy was applied. Do not treat one contractor's policy as a national rule, and do not treat a private plan's week count as a Medicare rule.

References: CMS fact sheet: CY 2018 outpatient rule, removal of total knee arthroplasty from the inpatient-only list · CMS: Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement frequently asked questions, total knee arthroplasty · CMS fact sheet: the two-midnight rule · CMS: Hip and knee replacement, inpatient or outpatient status and the two-midnight rule

How does inpatient or outpatient status change the bill?

CMS's two-midnight fact sheet says the choice between an inpatient admission and outpatient treatment has significant implications for beneficiary cost sharing, because Medicare pays inpatient hospital care and outpatient hospital care differently. Outpatient care can include observation. Days spent as an outpatient do not count toward the three-day inpatient stay that Medicare requires before it covers skilled nursing facility care. The fact sheet does not state a dollar amount for what you owe, and this page does not either. If the dispute is the hospital admission rather than the knee procedure, see a hospital stay denial.

Medicare.gov explains whether a hospital stay was inpatient or outpatient, including observation. What that status does to the bill is in a Medicare observation status bill. If Medicare will not cover the skilled nursing stay that follows, see a Medicare skilled nursing coverage denial. If the dispute is the rehabilitation admission after the surgery, see an inpatient rehabilitation denial. An out-of-network surgeon's bill at an in-network hospital is a different problem. See a surprise bill from a surgeon.

References: CMS fact sheet: the two-midnight rule · Medicare.gov: Inpatient or outpatient hospital status

What rules apply to a Medicare Advantage plan?

42 CFR 422.101(b) says a Medicare Advantage organization must follow CMS national coverage determinations, general coverage and benefit conditions in traditional Medicare, and written local coverage decisions for the area. The regulation names the payment criteria for inpatient admissions at 42 CFR 412.3 and the procedures the Secretary designates as requiring inpatient care under 42 CFR 419.22(n). 42 CFR 422.101(c) says the organization must base medical necessity determinations on those coverage criteria, on whether the item is reasonable and necessary, and on the enrollee's medical history, physician recommendations, and clinical notes. It may not deny a basic benefit based on criteria outside that section. When Medicare coverage criteria are not fully established, 42 CFR 422.101(b)(6) allows publicly accessible internal criteria that meet the tests in that paragraph. Ask the plan whether the criterion it used is a national coverage determination, a local coverage determination, or its own policy, and ask for a copy.

42 CFR 422.138 says that when a coordinated care plan uses prior authorization for a basic or supplemental benefit, it may use that process only to confirm the diagnoses or other medical criteria that support coverage, to make sure a basic benefit is medically necessary under the standards in 42 CFR 422.101(c)(1), or to make sure a supplemental benefit is clinically appropriate. If the plan approved the service through prior authorization, or through a pre-service or concurrent decision, it may not later deny coverage for lack of medical necessity, and it may not reopen that decision, except for good cause or if there is reliable evidence of fraud or similar fault. The same section says a private fee-for-service plan is not permitted to use prior authorization. 42 CFR 422.137 says a plan may not use a utilization-management policy, including prior authorization, on or after January 1, 2024, unless its utilization-management committee has reviewed and approved that policy.

42 CFR 422.101(c) requires the plan to consider the physician's recommendations and the clinical notes. Ask the plan whether the treating clinician can discuss those records with the plan's reviewer. That discussion does not replace the written appeal, and it does not move the deadline on the notice unless the notice says it does. The plan's appeal is in how to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial.

References: 42 CFR 422.101: Medicare Advantage basic benefits, including traditional Medicare coverage criteria · 42 CFR 422.138: Medicare Advantage prior authorization · 42 CFR 422.137: Medicare Advantage utilization management committee

How do I appeal a knee replacement denial?

For Original Medicare, 42 CFR 405.942 says a redetermination must be filed within 120 calendar days after you receive the notice of the initial determination. Receipt is presumed five calendar days after the date on the notice, unless there is evidence otherwise. The steps are in how to appeal an Original Medicare denial. A dispute about whether a hospital stay should have been inpatient is the appeal described in a Medicare observation status bill. Use the notice that matches the decision you are challenging.

For a private plan, HealthCare.gov says to file an internal appeal within 180 days of receiving the denial notice. 29 CFR 2560.503-1 gives a group health plan at least 180 days. 45 CFR 147.136 applies that standard to non-grandfathered coverage and generally does not apply to a grandfathered plan, except that external review can still apply to some surprise out-of-network emergency, facility, and air-ambulance bills. If the notice gives a later date, use the notice. If the denial involves medical judgment, HealthCare.gov says you can request an external review in writing within 4 months after the plan's own review. The steps are in how to appeal a health insurance denial and how to request an external review. Send the imaging, the notes of conservative care the policy asked for, and your clinician's response to the criterion the plan named. If the denial is for cataract surgery rather than a knee replacement, see a cataract surgery denial.

References: 42 CFR 405.942: Original Medicare redetermination filing deadline · Medicare.gov: Appeals in Original Medicare · HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · HealthCare.gov: External review · 29 CFR 2560.503-1: Claims procedure, including the 180-day appeal period · U.S. Department of Labor: Filing a claim for your health benefits · 45 CFR 147.136: Internal claims, appeals, and external review

What this page cannot promise

This is general information, not legal or medical advice. Removing total knee arthroplasty from the inpatient-only list did not require outpatient surgery, and it did not guarantee Part A payment for a short stay. A plan's conservative-care policy can still be the basis for a denial. A clinician's call to the plan does not, by itself, appeal the denial. Nothing on this page promises that Medicare or a plan will approve the surgery or change the hospital status.

Sources and further help

These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.

Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.

Report a broken link or suggest a correction.

← Explore all 141 guides