Skip to content
BillHelp
Menu
YOUR BILLHELP GUIDE

Billed Out of Network After the Directory Said In Network

What can I do if a directory listed the doctor as in network and the bill says out of network?

Save the directory page, printout, or written reply that listed the doctor as in network, and ask the plan to charge you no more than in-network cost sharing for a covered service. A federal statute can require that limit when you relied on the plan's directory, its online database, or its reply. It applies to group health plans and to group or individual health insurance. Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, VA, and Indian Health Service use other rules. This page explains the statute and how to dispute the bill. It does not promise a refund.

Get help with my bill →
General U.S. guidance. Your plan documents and denial notice explain the process that applies to your case. Medicare, Medicaid, and other programs may use different rules. This is not medical or legal advice, and no result is guaranteed.

What should I keep?

The statute and CMS pages below were checked on November 16, 2026. Save the proof that you relied on before you call.

Keep a screenshot or print of the directory or the online database, with the date if the page shows one. Keep any written reply, email, or letter in which the plan said the provider or facility was in network. If you called, ask the plan for the written reply it is supposed to keep. Write down the date you looked, the provider's name, and the address on the listing. Also keep the bill, the explanation of benefits, and any note that says the provider was out of network.

Ask the plan for the network status it used for that provider, that facility, and that date of care. A hospital and a doctor who works there can be listed differently. How to read an out-of-network bill in general is in an out-of-network medical bill.

References: 42 U.S.C. 300gg-115: Provider directory information and cost sharing when that information is wrong

When does the directory rule limit what I pay?

For plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2022, 42 U.S.C. 300gg-115 applies to a group health plan and to a health insurance issuer offering group or individual health insurance coverage. If a nonparticipating provider or facility furnishes an item or service that would have been covered had a participating provider or facility furnished it, and one of two tests is met, the plan must not impose cost sharing greater than the in-network amount. It must also apply the deductible or out-of-pocket maximum that would have applied if a participating provider or facility had furnished the service.

The first test is that you received information, through the plan's database, provider directory, or response protocol, that the provider was participating or the facility was participating, for that item or service. The second test is that the information was not provided as the statute requires, you asked through the plan's response protocol whether the provider or facility was participating, and you were told that it was. A listing you never saw, and a call you never made, is not one of those two tests. The statute is the text to use. CMS's shorter overview says that if the directory has the wrong information and you receive out-of-network care as a result, cost sharing cannot be higher than the in-network amount. CMS's plan-duties page says the plan applies in-network cost sharing when the database, the directory, or the response protocol gave inaccurate network-status information.

The same statute says the plan must verify and update directory information at least once every 90 days, update the database within 2 business days of receiving directory information from a provider or facility, and have a way to remove a provider it cannot verify. For a telephone question about whether a provider or facility is in network, the plan must respond as soon as practicable and no later than 1 business day, in writing, electronic or print as you request, and it must keep that communication in your file for at least 2 years. A print directory must say the information was accurate as of the publication date and that you should check the database or contact the plan for the current listing. The statute says it does not preempt a state law on provider directories. This page does not list state laws.

The service has to be one the plan would have covered in network. The statute does not add a benefit the plan excludes. Cost sharing can still include a copay, coinsurance, or deductible, at the in-network level. CMS's consumer overview also says the plan must count that cost sharing toward any in-network deductible and in-network out-of-pocket maximum, and include certain surprise-billing disclosures on the explanation of benefits.

References: 42 U.S.C. 300gg-115: Provider directory information and cost sharing when that information is wrong · CMS: No Surprises Act key consumer protections · CMS: No Surprises Act duties of plans and issuers, including provider directories

Which plans does this rule cover, and what if I already paid?

The statute names a group health plan and an issuer of group or individual health insurance coverage. CMS's page on the new protections describes No Surprises Act rules for people who get coverage through an employer, including a federal, state, or local government, through the Marketplace, or directly through an individual plan, beginning January 2022. That page says the rules do not apply to people with coverage through Medicare, Medicaid, Indian Health Services, Veterans Affairs health care, or TRICARE, because those programs have other protections. If you have one of those programs, use the notice that program sent. Do not send a Medicare or Medicaid dispute to a commercial plan's directory process.

CMS's consumer overview says you are entitled to a full refund from the provider of any amount you paid over the in-network cost sharing, plus interest, if you received out-of-network care because of inaccurate provider information, the provider or facility billed you for more than the in-network cost sharing, and you paid the bill. CMS's directory training says the provider must not bill you more than the in-network cost sharing, and that the interest rate is to be set by the Secretary of Health and Human Services through rulemaking. That training, and the consumer overview, both say the Departments expected to issue regulations to implement this directory provision, and that in the meantime plans and issuers are expected to use a good faith, reasonable interpretation of the statute. On November 16, 2026, 45 CFR part 149, the surprise-billing regulation, did not contain a section stating this directory cost-sharing rule or an interest rate. Use the statute, and ask the plan to apply it. Do not quote an interest percentage. This page does not state one.

Other No Surprises Act limits, including emergency care and care at an in-network facility, are in the No Surprises Act. A bill that is higher than the plan's allowed amount for a different reason is in a balance-billing dispute.

References: CMS: What the No Surprises Act protects, and which programs are outside it · CMS: No Surprises Act key consumer protections · CMS: No Surprises Act training on provider directories and the cost-sharing limit · 42 U.S.C. 300gg-115: Provider directory information and cost sharing when that information is wrong

How do I dispute a directory-error bill?

Write to the plan and to the provider. Include the date of care, the claim number, the amount the bill asks for, and the amount the explanation of benefits says you owe. Attach the directory page, database page, or written reply you relied on. Ask the plan to reprocess the claim at in-network cost sharing, to count that amount toward the in-network deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, and to send a corrected explanation of benefits. Ask the provider to bill no more than that in-network amount and, if you already paid more, to refund the difference. Ask for both answers in writing.

You can submit a complaint if you believe the provider, the facility, or the insurer is not following the No Surprises Act. CMS's consumer page says phone support is available 7 days a week at 1-800-985-3059. A complaint is not the plan's appeal. If the plan denies the service itself, or refuses to reprocess the claim, use the appeal instructions and the deadline on that notice. See how to appeal a health insurance denial. If the clinician is someone you never met, such as a radiologist or anesthesiologist at an in-network facility, that bill has a separate limit. See a bill from a doctor you never saw.

References: CMS: No Surprises Act help for consumers · CMS: Your medical bill rights when using insurance · HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals

When should I get more help?

Ask for help if you cannot find the listing you used, the appeal date is close, or the plan and the provider disagree about whether the directory rule applies. Call the plan at the number on your card, and use 1-800-985-3059 for a No Surprises Act question. If the coverage is insurance a state regulates, the state insurance department is another place to complain. A review of the listing and the bill can sort which rule applies. It cannot promise that the bill will be reduced. A provider who leaves the network after you started care is a different problem from a directory that was wrong on the day of the visit. See a doctor who left the network during treatment.

What this page cannot promise

This is general information, not legal advice. The statute's limit depends on what you were told, through the directory, the database, or the plan's reply, and on whether the service would have been covered in network. A plan can still apply in-network cost sharing. Medicare, Medicaid, and the other programs CMS lists are outside this rule. CMS has described the directory provision as one that plans should apply under a good faith reading of the statute while regulations were still expected. Nothing on this page promises a refund, a particular interest amount, or a lower bill.

Sources and further help

These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.

Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.

Report a broken link or suggest a correction.

← Explore all 141 guides