Doctor Left the Network During Treatment
What can I do if my doctor or hospital left my plan's network during treatment?
A doctor or hospital leaving your network does not always mean you must pay out-of-network rates for care already underway. For many group health plans, and for group or individual health insurance, a federal continuity rule can let a continuing care patient elect to keep that provider on the terms that would have applied, for up to 90 days. You have to qualify, and you may have to tell the plan. Medicare Advantage uses different rules. This page explains what to ask. It does not promise the bill will be repriced.
Get help with my bill →Start with which change this was
Write down what changed, and the date you learned about it. The federal continuity statute is not a general promise that every doctor who leaves a network stays in network. It applies only in the situations the statute lists, and only for a person the statute calls a continuing care patient. A directory that was already wrong on the day of the visit is a different problem. See a bill after a provider-directory error. An ordinary out-of-network bill, with no continuity election, is in an out-of-network medical bill.
The plan-side rule is 42 U.S.C. 300gg-113, Public Health Service Act section 2799A-3. The same protection is Internal Revenue Code section 9818 and ERISA section 718. CMS's October 2023 citation chart lists those three together. The triggering changes are: the provider's or facility's contract is terminated, which includes expiration or nonrenewal but not a termination for quality standards or fraud; benefits end because the terms of that provider's participation change; or the contract between the group health plan and the issuer ends and that ending cuts off benefits for that provider. A quality or fraud removal is outside the definition. Choosing a new plan yourself is not automatically the third category. Ask which change the plan says happened. A new Medicare Advantage enrollment uses the Medicare section below.
Who is a continuing care patient?
The statute defines a continuing care patient as a person who, with respect to that provider or facility, is in one of five situations. First, the person is undergoing a course of treatment for a serious and complex condition. Second, the person is undergoing a course of institutional or inpatient care. Third, the person is scheduled to undergo nonelective surgery from the provider, including postoperative care from that provider or facility for that surgery. Fourth, the person is pregnant and undergoing a course of treatment for the pregnancy. Fifth, the person is or was determined to be terminally ill, as determined under 42 U.S.C. 1395x(dd)(3)(A), and is receiving treatment for that illness from that provider or facility.
A serious and complex condition has its own definition. For an acute illness, it is a condition serious enough to require specialized medical treatment to avoid the reasonable possibility of death or permanent harm. For a chronic illness or condition, it must be life-threatening, degenerative, potentially disabling, or congenital, and it must require specialized medical care over a prolonged period of time. The statute does not give a longer list of diagnoses. A routine checkup, or a condition that does not meet those words, may not qualify. Ask the plan which part of the definition it applied, and ask your treating clinician for a short description of the course of treatment if the plan asks for one.
The terminal-illness category uses the Medicare definition in 42 U.S.C. 1395x(dd)(3)(A). This page does not restate that definition. Ask which determination the plan used. This page also does not add a definition of institutional care or nonelective surgery beyond the statute's words.
References: 42 U.S.C. 300gg-113: Continuity of care, Public Health Service Act section 2799A-3 · CMS: No Surprises Act legal citations, revised October 2023, including continuity of care
How long can the old terms last, and what must the provider accept?
If you are a continuing care patient when one of those changes hits your provider, the plan or issuer must notify you, on a timely basis, of the termination and of the right to elect transitional care. It must let you say you need that care. It must let you elect to continue the items and services that would have been covered, under the same terms and conditions, for the course of treatment tied to your continuing-care status. The period starts on the notice date and ends on the earlier of 90 days or the date you are no longer a continuing care patient for that provider. "On a timely basis" is not a number of days in the statute. If no notice arrived, ask for it and for how to elect. Do not assume the old cost sharing continues without an election.
Public Health Service Act section 2799B-8, 42 U.S.C. 300gg-138, applies to the provider or facility when coverage is provided under that continuity section. The provider must accept the plan's payment, plus your cost sharing under the continuity section, as payment in full, and must keep following the plan's policies, procedures, and quality standards as if the termination had not occurred. That duty is for the covered transitional items and services, not for care outside the period or outside the course of treatment.
The statute applies to an individual with benefits under a group health plan, or under group or individual health insurance coverage offered by a health insurance issuer. The effective-date note says it applies for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2022. FAQ Part 49 says the same, and says that in the individual market the date is the policy year. Medicare, Medicaid, and other programs are outside that sentence. If your coverage is one of those programs, use the sections below. The surprise-billing rules for an emergency, or for an out-of-network clinician at an in-network facility, are also different. See the No Surprises Act.
References: 42 U.S.C. 300gg-113: Continuity of care, Public Health Service Act section 2799A-3 · 42 U.S.C. 300gg-138: Provider continuity of care, Public Health Service Act section 2799B-8 · DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 49, August 20, 2021, including continuity of care · CMS: No Surprises Act legal citations, revised October 2023, including continuity of care
Have final continuity-of-care rules been issued?
FAQ Part 49, from the Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and the Treasury on August 20, 2021, said the Departments did not expect to issue continuity-of-care regulations before January 1, 2022. Any later rule would have a prospective date and time to comply. Until rulemaking to fully implement these provisions is adopted and applicable, plans, issuers, providers, and facilities are expected to use a good faith, reasonable interpretation of the statute. The November 23, 2021 Federal Register preamble on prescription-drug and health-care spending repeated that good-faith instruction for section 113, continuity of care, until full implementing rules are finalized and effective.
CMS's legal-citations chart, revised October 2023, puts an asterisk, not a regulation, in the column for section 113. The chart says an asterisk generally means no corresponding regulation has been issued yet, and that the chart is not law. The FAQ Part 49 page says some of Parts 49 and 53 were superseded by FAQ Part 61. The Department's FAQ index describes Part 61 as Transparency in Coverage. The continuity answer is still on the Part 49 page. Ask the plan which instructions it uses now, and ask for a citation if it names a regulation.
References: DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 49, August 20, 2021, including continuity of care · Federal Register, November 23, 2021: good-faith implementation until continuity-of-care rules are final · CMS: No Surprises Act legal citations, revised October 2023, including continuity of care
What are the Medicare Advantage rules?
The No Surprises Act continuity section above is not the Medicare Advantage rule. Medicare Advantage coordinated care plans have their own access and continuity rules in 42 CFR 422.112. A coordinated care plan must maintain a network. It must arrange for and cover any medically necessary covered benefit outside that network, at in-network cost sharing, when an in-network provider or benefit is unavailable or inadequate to meet an enrollee's medical needs. That is a network-adequacy rule. It is not the same as an automatic 90-day election every time a doctor leaves.
42 CFR 422.112(b)(8) covers prior authorization for basic benefits when you are in an active course of treatment. An approval must last as long as medically necessary to avoid a disruption, using the coverage criteria, your history, and the treating provider's recommendation. A separate minimum 90-day transition applies when you enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan after a course of treatment has already started, even if the provider is out of network. That includes people new to a plan and people new to Medicare. For those 90 days the plan must not disrupt the active course of treatment or make you get a new authorization. A course of treatment is a prescribed order for a specific person and condition, decided ahead of time with you and the provider. It need not be a formal treatment plan. Active means you are seeing the provider and following that order. This 90-day rule is for new enrollment. It is not the commercial election for a doctor who leaves.
When a contracted provider leaves, 42 CFR 422.111(e) requires notice whether the termination is for cause or without cause. The section also cites 42 CFR 422.2267(e)(12), which this page does not restate. For primary care or behavioral health, the organization must send written notice and make one phone attempt, for enrollees who have not opted out of plan-business calls, at least 45 days before the end date. That notice goes to enrollees assigned to that primary care provider and to enrollees who were patients of that primary care or behavioral health provider in the past three years. For other specialties, written notice is due at least 30 days before the end date to enrollees seen regularly: assigned to the provider, currently receiving care, or treated in the past three months. A for-cause termination requires a good-faith effort to meet those timeframes.
If a Medicare Advantage plan denied the care, the appeal path is the plan's. See how to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial. Ask whether you are being treated as a new enrollee in an active course of treatment, whether the plan says the network is inadequate, and whether a termination notice was sent.
References: 42 CFR 422.112: Medicare Advantage access to services and continuity of care · 42 CFR 422.111: Medicare Advantage information, including provider-termination notices
What about Medicaid, and can state law add a protection?
Medicaid managed care uses 42 CFR 438.62, not the commercial election. The state must keep services going when a managed-care contract ends, and when someone is disenrolled for a reason other than losing Medicaid. It must have a public transition policy for a move between managed-care plans, or from fee-for-service into managed care, if a gap would seriously harm the person or risk hospitalization or institutionalization. The policy must let the person keep the current provider for a period of time if that provider is out of the new network. The regulation does not set that period at 90 days. Ask the state Medicaid agency or the plan for its policy.
State law may add a continuity protection for some plans. This page does not name a state statute. Before you rely on one, ask your state insurance department what it enforces, and ask the plan which rule it is applying.
References: 42 CFR 438.62: Medicaid managed-care continued services and transition of care
What should I ask, and when do I appeal?
Send one written request to the plan, and keep a copy. Use the member number, the provider's name, and the date you were told the network changed.
If the plan denies the election, or pays the claim as out of network, use the appeal instructions on that notice. A commercial internal appeal and external review are explained in how to appeal a health insurance denial. The deadline on your notice controls. This page does not substitute a different deadline.
- Ask which of the three statutory changes the plan says occurred, and whether it says the termination was for quality or fraud.
- Ask whether it treats you as a continuing care patient, and which of the five categories it is using.
- Ask for the notice, the date of the notice, and how to elect transitional care. Ask the end date it is using, which is the earlier of 90 days after the notice or the date you are no longer a continuing care patient.
- Ask the provider to accept the plan payment and your in-network cost sharing as payment in full for items and services covered under that election, which is what 42 U.S.C. 300gg-138 requires when that coverage is provided.
- If the coverage is Medicare Advantage or Medicaid, ask for the rule in the sections above instead of the commercial election.
References: 42 U.S.C. 300gg-113: Continuity of care, Public Health Service Act section 2799A-3 · 42 U.S.C. 300gg-138: Provider continuity of care, Public Health Service Act section 2799B-8 · HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · HealthCare.gov: External review
What this page cannot promise
This is general information, not medical or legal advice. The commercial protection depends on the type of plan, the kind of contract change, and whether you are a continuing care patient who elects transitional care. The statute does not set a numbered deadline for the notice, and the October 2023 CMS chart did not list a final regulation for this section. A Medicare Advantage 90-day transition is for a new enrollee already in a course of treatment, plus the separate notice and network rules above. A state rule may be different, and this page does not state one. Nothing here promises that a plan will reprice a bill or that a provider will keep you as a patient.
Sources and further help
These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.
- 42 U.S.C. 300gg-113: Continuity of care, Public Health Service Act section 2799A-3 ↗
- 42 U.S.C. 300gg-138: Provider continuity of care, Public Health Service Act section 2799B-8 ↗
- CMS: No Surprises Act legal citations, revised October 2023, including continuity of care ↗
- DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 49, August 20, 2021, including continuity of care ↗
- Federal Register, November 23, 2021: good-faith implementation until continuity-of-care rules are final ↗
- 42 CFR 422.112: Medicare Advantage access to services and continuity of care ↗
- 42 CFR 422.111: Medicare Advantage information, including provider-termination notices ↗
- 42 CFR 438.62: Medicaid managed-care continued services and transition of care ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals ↗
- HealthCare.gov: External review ↗
Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.