Claim Denial Codes on an EOB, Explained
What do the codes on an EOB or a denial notice mean?
Those codes are the plan's short labels for how it processed a claim. On an explanation of benefits (EOB) or a denial notice, a two-letter group code such as CO or PR generally says who the plan assigns an adjustment to, and a claim adjustment reason code, often a number, says why the payment differs from the billed charge. A remark code, often an N code, an M code, or an MA code, adds detail. Look beside each service line, and check the bottom of the EOB, where plans often print a plain-language key.
Get help with my bill →Where to look on the EOB
CMS says an explanation of benefits is not a bill. It shows the provider charges, the allowed charges, what the plan paid, and what you owe. CMS calls that amount the patient balance, and says your provider bill should not be higher than the patient balance.
X12 publishes claim adjustment reason codes so a plan can explain why it paid a claim, or one line on a claim, at an amount different from the provider's bill. The two letters in front of the number are the group code. X12 says a group code generally assigns responsibility for the adjustment, and that a group code is always two letters. You may see the pair written as CO-45, CO 45, or CO45. You may also see only a sentence.
CMS says a remark code is the plan's note with further explanation of the costs, the charges, and the paid amounts. CMS says that code is usually two or three characters, letters and numbers together, and that the bottom of the EOB is where to read what each code means.
References: CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits · X12: Claim adjustment reason codes
What CO, PR, OA, and PI mean
X12 says these two-letter codes generally assign responsibility for the adjustment. The name tells you how the plan classified the amount. Compare that amount with the patient balance before you treat it as a bill.
X12 also lists CR, corrections and reversal, and says not to use CR with version 005010 and later. If an older notice shows CR, ask the plan what that amount is.
- CO, contractual obligation. X12 uses CO when the amount is not your responsibility under any circumstances, because of a contract between the provider and the plan or because of a regulation. Compare it with the patient balance. If a bill asks you to pay a CO amount, ask the plan and the billing office to explain that charge.
- PR, patient responsibility. The plan is assigning this amount to you. On the X12 list, reason code 1 is the deductible amount, reason code 2 is the coinsurance amount, and reason code 3 is the co-payment amount. A PR code can also appear with other reason codes. Match the amount to your plan before you pay. See the EOB and the bill.
- OA, other adjustment. X12 uses this label for an other adjustment. X12 says the label does not by itself say who owes the amount. Ask the plan what the adjustment is and who it expects to pay.
- PI, payer-initiated reductions. X12 uses PI when, in the plan's view, the amount is not your responsibility, and there is no contract between the provider and the plan that supports the reduction. Ask what was reduced, and compare the amount with the patient balance.
References: X12: Claim adjustment reason codes · X12: Interpretation of group code CO · X12: Interpretation of group codes PI, OA, CO, and PR · CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits
Common claim adjustment reason codes
A claim adjustment reason code, often called a CARC, is the number that says why the payment differs from the billed charge. The notes below are plain-language paraphrases of the current X12 list, checked on November 14, 2026. They are not the official wording. Use the X12 page in the sources for the official text. If your code is not here, call the plan and ask it to explain the code in writing.
Read the group code together with the reason code. Some numbers are used with more than one group code. X12 says to use code 45 only with PR or CO, depending on who the plan holds liable.
- 4. The procedure code is inconsistent with the modifier used with it. Ask the provider's billing office to compare both with your record. See how to fix a coding error.
- 16. The claim or service is missing information, or the plan says there is a submission or billing error. X12 says this code is not for a missing attachment or other documentation. X12 also says a remark code must be provided with it, and that an alert-only remark is not enough. Read that remark, then ask the plan what is missing or what was wrong on the claim. See a denial for missing information.
- 18. The plan is treating this claim or service as an exact duplicate. X12 says to pair this reason with group code OA, except where a state workers' compensation rule requires CO. Ask which claim was already processed, and whether this line is the same service. See a duplicate-claim denial.
- 22. The plan says this care may be covered by another payer under coordination of benefits. Ask which other plan it has on file, and for which dates. See a coordination-of-benefits denial.
- 27. The plan says the expense was incurred after your coverage ended. Compare the service date with the date coverage ended. See a denial for inactive coverage.
- 29. The plan says the time limit for filing the claim has passed. Ask who was supposed to file, when the claim was sent, and whether a corrected claim can still be reviewed. See when the doctor misses timely filing.
- 45. The charge exceeds a fee schedule, a maximum allowable amount, or a contracted or legislated fee arrangement. X12 says this adjustment cannot equal the total charge for the service or the claim, must not repeat a payment or contractual reduction an earlier payer already applied, and is used only with group code PR or CO depending on who the plan holds liable. If the group code is CO, the amount is not your responsibility under any circumstances. If it is PR, the plan assigned it to you. Ask the plan to explain which one is on your notice. See a balance-billing dispute and a bill that continues after insurance paid.
- 50. The plan does not consider the service medically necessary, and it is treating the service as not covered. Ask for the rule it used, and ask your clinician for the records that address that rule. See a medical-necessity denial.
- 96. The plan says the charge is not covered. X12 says a remark code must be provided with it, and that an alert-only remark is not enough. Read the remark, then ask which benefit or exclusion the plan is using. See a service-not-covered denial.
- 97. The plan says the benefit for this service is included in the payment or allowance for another service or procedure it has already decided. That is a different problem from an exact duplicate, which is code 18. Ask which other service this benefit was included in, and ask the billing office to explain the codes. See a coding review.
- 109. This payer says the claim or service is not covered by this payer and should be sent to the correct payer. Ask which plan should receive it, and ask the provider to bill that plan. If the question is which plan pays first, see coordination of benefits. A claim sent to the wrong insurance is one example. See a real example. If the hospital keeps sending the claim to the wrong plan, see a hospital that billed the wrong insurance.
- 119. The plan says a benefit limit for this period of time, or for this occurrence, has been used up. Ask which limit was reached, for which dates, and where that limit is written in your plan. If the service is physical therapy, see physical therapy visits denied.
- 197. The plan says precertification, authorization, notification, or pre-treatment was missing. Ask whether the plan required one of those before the care, whether a request was sent, and what it would accept now. See a prior-authorization denial.
- 204. The plan says this service, this equipment, or this drug is not a covered benefit on your current plan. Ask for the benefit language it used, and compare that language with the care you received. See a service-not-covered denial.
- 242. The plan says the provider who performed the service was not a network provider or a primary care provider. Ask whether that provider was in network on the date of care, and whether the plan required your primary care provider. See an out-of-network bill. Code 243 is a different code: a network or primary care provider did not authorize the service. If 243 is the code on your notice, see a missing-referral denial.
References: X12: Claim adjustment reason codes · X12: Interpretation of group code CO
What remark codes add
A remittance advice remark code, often called a RARC, adds detail. X12 says these codes do two jobs. Most of them explain an adjustment that already has a claim adjustment reason code. X12 calls those supplemental remark codes. The other kind is an alert. An alert begins with the word Alert. X12 uses an alert to pass along a processing note. An alert is not the reason for one particular adjustment.
On an EOB, you may see a short code or only the plan's sentence. Many remark codes start with M, N, or MA. CMS says to check the bottom of the EOB for the description. When a reason code such as 16 or 96 requires a remark code, read that remark before you decide what is missing or why the charge was not covered. This page does not list remark-code meanings. The official list is the X12 page in the sources.
References: X12: Remittance advice remark codes · CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits · X12: Claim adjustment reason codes
What to do after you read the code
The code is a starting point. A plan chooses which code to print. Many plans print a sentence instead of a code, or next to the code. Two plans can describe similar problems with different codes. The code alone does not decide whether the bill is correct.
Call the number on your insurance card or on the EOB. Ask the plan to explain the group code, the reason code, and any remark code in writing, and to name the plan rule it used. For many private plans, HealthCare.gov says the insurer must notify you in writing and explain why a claim was denied. CMS says you can appeal if the plan refuses to pay a bill, and that the plan must tell you why. Your notice has the deadline and the address. Medicare, Medicaid, and some employer plans use different appeal rules. An Original Medicare denial on a Medicare Summary Notice is explained in how to appeal an Original Medicare denial. Follow the notice for your plan.
Compare that written reason with the provider bill. See how an EOB differs from a medical bill, how to appeal a denial, and letter templates if you need to write to the plan or the billing office.
References: HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · CMS: Action plan for a denied insurance claim · CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits
What does CO mean on an EOB?
CO means contractual obligation. X12 uses that group code when the amount is not your responsibility under any circumstances, because of a contract between the provider and the plan or because of a regulation. Compare the amount with the patient balance. CMS says the provider bill should not be higher than that patient balance.
References: X12: Claim adjustment reason codes · X12: Interpretation of group code CO · CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits
What does PR mean on an EOB?
PR means patient responsibility. The plan is assigning that amount to you. On the X12 list, reason code 1 is the deductible amount, reason code 2 is the coinsurance amount, and reason code 3 is the co-payment amount. A PR code can also appear with other reason codes. Match the amount to your plan before you pay.
References: X12: Claim adjustment reason codes
What is a claim adjustment reason code?
A claim adjustment reason code is the number that explains why a claim or service line was paid differently than it was billed. X12 publishes the list. Patients usually see the number next to a group code, such as CO with 45 or PR with 1. If the sentence on your EOB is unclear, call the plan and ask for the reason in writing.
References: X12: Claim adjustment reason codes
What is a remark code on an EOB?
A remark code adds detail to an adjustment that already has a reason code, or it is an alert about how the remittance was processed. An alert is not the reason for one particular adjustment. X12 calls these remittance advice remark codes. CMS says the code on an EOB is usually two or three characters of letters and numbers, and that the description is at the bottom of the EOB. Many of these codes start with M, N, or MA.
References: X12: Remittance advice remark codes · CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits
What should I do if I disagree with the code?
Call the plan and ask for the reason in writing, including the plan rule it used. Then follow the appeal instructions on your notice. CMS says you have the right to appeal if the plan refuses to pay a bill. A phone call may not be the appeal itself. See how to appeal a denial and letter templates.
References: CMS: Action plan for a denied insurance claim · HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals
Sources and further help
These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.
- CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits ↗
- X12: Claim adjustment reason codes ↗
- X12: Interpretation of group code CO ↗
- X12: Interpretation of group codes PI, OA, CO, and PR ↗
- X12: Remittance advice remark codes ↗
- CMS: Action plan for a denied insurance claim ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals ↗
Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.