Hospital Billed the Wrong Insurance
What can I do if the hospital billed the wrong insurance and sent me the bill?
If the hospital billed an old plan, or the wrong plan, the claim can be denied and the statement can come to you even though you had coverage. Give the hospital the correct plan name, member ID, and the dates that plan covered you, in writing, and ask it to rebill. Ask it to hold the account out of collections while that rebill is pending. A rebill can still miss a filing deadline, and Medicare may not be the plan that pays first. This page explains those steps. It does not promise the new claim will be paid.
Get help with my bill →What should I give the hospital in writing?
Get the denial or the statement in front of you. Write down the plan name the hospital used, the member ID it used, and the date of service. Compare that with the card that was active on the date of the care, not the card you have today if it changed. A denial that says you were not enrolled can be an old ID. See a denial for inactive coverage. A denial that says another payer should have been billed can be coordination of benefits. See a coordination-of-benefits denial. One published example is a dermatology bill sent to the wrong insurance, described on the case studies page.
Keep a copy of both cards if you changed plans, and write the date the new coverage started. If an employer or the Marketplace changed your member ID and you stayed on the same plan, say that too. The hospital needs the ID that was active on the service date. Ask the plan for that start date in writing, and attach the reply to the rebill request so the billing office is not guessing from the card in your wallet today.
Send the billing office a short letter or portal message. Include your name, date of birth, the account number, the date of service, the correct plan name, the member ID, and the group number if you have one. Attach a copy of the card if the office asks for it. Ask the office to confirm, in writing, the plan and member ID it will use on the new claim. Keep the confirmation. If the hospital bills the old plan again, send the same packet again and ask what system is still storing the old ID.
Medicare.gov says that if your coverage changes, tell your doctor and other health care provider about the change when you get care. Do that for this stay even if the care already happened. Tell every group that might bill separately, not only the hospital. A doctor who saw you in the hospital may have a different billing office and a different claim. Send that office the same plan information. A second bill is not proof the hospital used the right plan.
References: Medicare.gov: How Medicare works with other insurance
Ask for a rebill, and ask them to hold the account
Ask for a rebill in the same writing. Ask for the date the new claim was submitted, the plan it was sent to, and the payer claim number when the plan assigns one. A statement that arrives before any explanation of benefits is not the plan's decision. See a hospital bill that arrives before insurance pays.
Ask the hospital, in the same letter, not to send the account to collections while the corrected claim is pending. That is a request. This page does not cite a rule that every hospital must pause collections because a claim is being rebilled. If a collector already has the account, or the hospital says the account was referred, use a medical bill sent to collections while insurance is pending. Give the collector and the hospital the same proof of the correct plan.
When an explanation of benefits arrives, match it to this account. CMS says an explanation of benefits is not a bill. It says What You Owe, or the Patient Balance, is the amount you owe after the insurer has paid everything else, and that your bill should not be higher than the Patient Balance. Do not pay the hospital's full charges because the first claim was denied for the wrong plan. If the Patient Balance is from the old plan's denial, wait for the explanation of benefits from the plan that should have been billed.
References: CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits
What filing deadline should I watch?
A corrected claim can still be late. The deadline belongs to the plan that should have received the claim, and it is often counted from the date of service, not from the day you noticed the error. Original Medicare's filing period, and what a late professional claim can mean for what the doctor may bill you, is explained in the doctor filed the claim too late. Do not copy that Medicare period onto a private plan or a Medicare Advantage plan. Ask the correct plan for its filing deadline in writing.
Ask the hospital two dates: the date it first billed any plan, and the date it billed the correct plan. If the correct plan denies the claim as late, ask the hospital for its timely-filing appeal or exception, and ask the plan whether a corrected claim is treated as a new filing. Those answers come from the plan and the hospital. This page does not set a number of days for a private plan.
If the deadline is close, say that in the letter and ask the hospital to submit the corrected claim now. Keep proof of the date you delivered the correct insurance information. That proof does not, by itself, extend a deadline. It shows when the hospital had the right plan.
If the hospital bills the old plan again, do not start over with a phone call only. Send the same written packet and ask which record still has the old member ID: registration, the billing system, or a physician group that copied the hospital's old card. Ask for the new claim number after the corrected submission. Two claim numbers are a sign to keep them separate, not a sign to pay both statements.
If both plans deny the claim, read the two reasons apart. One denial may say "bill the other payer." The other may say you were not enrolled, or that the claim was late, or that information was missing. Fix the reason each letter actually gives. A coordination update, an enrollment correction, and a late-filing question are three different requests. Sending one appeal that argues all of them at once can miss the deadline printed on the notice that matters. Use each notice's instructions.
What if Medicare and another plan are both involved?
Medicare.gov says that if you have Medicare and other health insurance, each type of coverage is a payer. The primary payer pays up to the limits of its coverage, then sends the rest of the balance to the secondary payer. If the secondary payer does not cover the remaining balance, you may be responsible for the rest. That order is called coordination of benefits. Who pays first depends on the type of coverage, and Medicare.gov has a tool on that page for the question. This page does not restate every situation in that tool.
Medicare.gov also says that if the insurance company does not pay the claim promptly, usually within 120 days, your doctor or other provider may bill Medicare. Medicare may make a conditional payment to pay the bill, and then later recover payments the primary payer should have made. A conditional payment is not a decision that Medicare was primary. If you have a question about who pays first, or if your coverage changes, Medicare.gov says to call the Benefits Coordination and Recovery Center at 1-855-798-2627. TTY users call 1-855-797-2627.
If the hospital billed Medicare when a group plan should have paid first, or billed the group plan when Medicare should have paid first, say that in the rebill request. Ask which payer the hospital will bill first, and ask both plans for the coordination record they have on file. Updating that record is the coordination problem in a coordination-of-benefits denial. It is not the same as an appeal, unless a plan has already issued a denial you disagree with.
References: Medicare.gov: How Medicare works with other insurance
When do I appeal instead of waiting for a rebill?
Use the plan appeal when the correct plan has denied the claim and you disagree, or when a plan will not correct an enrollment or coordination record. The notice states the deadline. HealthCare.gov's internal-appeal and external-review pages describe those steps for plans that use them. See how to appeal a health insurance denial. A rebill request to the hospital is not that appeal. Do both when both are needed: ask the hospital to send the claim to the right plan, and appeal if the right plan denies it.
If the denial says coverage was inactive, compare the service date with the plan's enrollment record before you appeal the medical care itself. A wrong end date is an enrollment correction. If the plan stands by the denial after that correction is refused, use the appeal instructions. If the only problem was an old card in the hospital's file, and the correct plan then pays, you may not need an appeal at all.
References: HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · HealthCare.gov: External review
What should I send, in one list?
Use one written request so the account note matches what you can prove you sent.
- The correct plan name, member ID, and the dates that coverage was active.
- A request to void or adjust the claim sent to the wrong plan and to submit a new claim to the correct plan.
- A request to hold the account from collections while the rebill is pending, and to confirm that hold in writing.
- A request for the correct plan's filing deadline, and for the date the new claim was submitted.
- If Medicare is involved, a request that the hospital follow the coordination order, and a note to call the Benefits Coordination and Recovery Center if the plans disagree about who pays first.
What this page cannot promise
This is general information, not legal advice. Asking for a rebill and a collections hold does not require the hospital to agree, and it does not extend a filing deadline. Medicare's coordination page decides who pays first only for the situations it describes, and a conditional payment can be recovered. A private plan uses its own deadline and its own appeal clock. Nothing on this page promises that the corrected claim will be paid or that a collector will stop.
Sources and further help
These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.
- Medicare.gov: How Medicare works with other insurance ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals ↗
- HealthCare.gov: External review ↗
- CMS: How to read an explanation of benefits ↗
Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.