Skip to content
BillHelp
Menu
YOUR BILLHELP GUIDE

Good Faith Estimate Dispute: When the Bill Is Higher

Can I dispute a bill that is much higher than my good faith estimate?

Sometimes. If you did not have health insurance, or you chose not to use it, and one provider's bill is at least $400 more than that provider's good faith estimate, you may be able to use a federal review called patient-provider dispute resolution. It has a deadline and a $25 fee. It does not apply if you used insurance. This page explains who gets an estimate, what it must include, and how the dispute works. It does not promise a lower bill.

Get help with my bill →
General U.S. guidance. Your plan documents and denial notice explain the process that applies to your case. Medicare, Medicaid, and other programs may use different rules. This is not medical or legal advice, and no result is guaranteed.

Who gets a good faith estimate

These rules were checked on the CMS pages and the federal regulations linked below on November 14, 2026. Use the current CMS dispute page when you file. The fee and the form live there. How an uninsured hospital patient uses the estimate together with charity care and Medicaid is in a hospital bill without insurance.

A good faith estimate is a list of expected charges before you get care. CMS says it is not a bill. CMS says you are given one only if you do not have health insurance or you are not using insurance to pay.

45 CFR 149.610 defines an uninsured or self-pay individual in two ways. One is a person who does not have benefits for that item or service under a group health plan, group or individual health insurance, a federal health care program, or a Federal Employees Health Benefits plan. The other is a person who does have benefits under a group health plan, health insurance, or a Federal Employees Health Benefits plan, but who is not seeking to have a claim submitted for that item or service.

CMS says to tell the provider in advance that you are not using insurance. You might do that because the service is not covered, or because paying directly costs less. The CMS dispute page says that, before the care, you told the provider you were not using insurance.

  • CMS says you get an estimate when you schedule care at least 3 business days in advance, or when you ask for one. CMS says business days are Monday through Friday.
  • CMS says you will not get an estimate during emergency care.
  • The rules apply to good faith estimates for care scheduled or requested on or after January 1, 2022.

References: CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance · 45 CFR 149.610, Good faith estimates for uninsured or self-pay patients · CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate

What the estimate must include

45 CFR 149.610 says a good faith estimate given to an uninsured or self-pay patient must include the items below. It also says the estimate must be in writing, on paper or electronically, in a form you can save and print. If you ask for it by phone or in person, the provider may tell you the information that way, but the regulation says the provider still has to give you the written estimate.

CMS's page for people not using insurance says that, currently, a good faith estimate lists expected charges for a single provider or facility, even when more than one provider will be involved. CMS says to request an estimate from each provider and from the facility. CMS also says the estimate should include expected charges for the items and services, including facility fees and hospital fees. Compare each bill with the estimate from that same provider or facility.

  • Your name and date of birth.
  • A plain description of the main item or service, and the scheduled date if there is one.
  • An itemized list of items and services reasonably expected for that period of care, grouped by provider or facility, with the applicable diagnosis codes, expected service codes, and expected charges for each listed item or service.
  • The name, National Provider Identifier, and tax identification number of each provider or facility on the estimate, and the state and the office or facility location where the care is expected.
  • A list of items or services the provider expects you to schedule separately, with a disclaimer that those items get their own estimates.
  • A disclaimer that other recommended items may have to be scheduled separately and are not on this estimate.
  • A disclaimer that the document is only an estimate of what was reasonably expected when it was issued, and that the actual items, services, or charges may differ.
  • A disclaimer that you can start the patient-provider dispute process if the billed charges are substantially higher than the expected charges, where to find instructions, and that starting the process will not affect the quality of your care.
  • A disclaimer that the estimate is not a contract and does not require you to get the care from the providers named on it.

References: 45 CFR 149.610, Good faith estimates for uninsured or self-pay patients · CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance

When the written estimate is due

CMS tells patients that providers must give a good faith estimate when you schedule care at least 3 business days in advance, or when you ask for one. You do not have to use the term "good faith." Ask for it in writing. CMS says you will need the estimate in writing to dispute the bill, and that you cannot use the dispute process without an estimate.

45 CFR 149.610 also sets deadlines, counted in business days, for the provider to issue that written estimate. The regulation lists them as alternatives, so use the deadline that matches how the care was set up:

  • If the care is scheduled at least 3 business days ahead, and the 10-day deadline below does not apply, no later than 1 business day after the date of scheduling.
  • If the care is scheduled at least 10 business days ahead, no later than 3 business days after the date of scheduling. This longer deadline is the one that applies to that appointment. It is not also due in 1 business day.
  • If you request an estimate, no later than 3 business days after the date of the request.

If the provider expects the scope to change, such as the charges, the items, or which provider will be involved, the regulation says you must get a new good faith estimate no later than 1 business day before the items or services are scheduled to be furnished. If the provider or facility changes less than 1 business day before that time, the regulation says the replacement must accept the expected charges from the estimate it is replacing. Keep the estimate you actually received. That is the one you compare with the bill.

References: CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance · 45 CFR 149.610, Good faith estimates for uninsured or self-pay patients

When you can use the dispute process

The federal process is called patient-provider dispute resolution. CMS says an independent reviewer looks at the bill and determines an appropriate payment. You can use it only if every condition on the current CMS dispute page is met. Checked on November 14, 2026, that page says you can dispute only if:

  • When you got care, you did not have health insurance, or you did not use it to pay.
  • Before the care, you told the provider you were not using insurance.
  • You got the care on or after January 1, 2022.
  • You have a good faith estimate that you received from the provider or facility three days before the scheduled appointment.
  • You have an initial bill dated within the last 120 calendar days, about 4 months.
  • One provider or facility charged at least $400 more than that provider's or facility's good faith estimate.

45 CFR 149.620 uses the same $400 test. It defines "substantially in excess" as total billed charges from a provider or facility that are at least $400 more than the total expected charges listed on the good faith estimate for that provider or facility. The total billed charges include items furnished with the main service, even if an item was not on the estimate. Compare one provider's bill with that provider's estimate. Do not add every bill from the visit and compare the sum with a single estimate.

45 CFR 149.620 has a separate rule when a co-provider or co-facility named on the estimate is replaced. The replacement's bill is compared with the expected charges for the original co-provider or co-facility, unless the replacement gave you a new good faith estimate. Then use the new estimate.

45 CFR 149.620 says HHS sends the dispute to a state process when that process meets the federal minimums. If the state charges a fee, the regulation says the fee cannot be higher than the federal fee. Start on the CMS dispute page. That page is the current federal instruction.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution · CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance

The filing deadline

Do not wait. The CMS pages and the regulation describe the 120 days in slightly different ways, and both were current on November 14, 2026.

The CMS dispute page says you qualify if the initial bill is dated within the last 120 calendar days. The CMS rights page says you have to start a dispute within 120 days of getting your initial bill. 45 CFR 149.620 says the notice that starts the dispute must be postmarked within 120 calendar days of receiving the initial bill that contains the charges at issue.

The date printed on the bill and the date you received it can be different. File while you still meet the test on the CMS dispute page, and do not let 120 calendar days pass after you receive the bill. The regulation says the date the process starts is the date HHS receives your notice.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

The $25 fee

45 CFR 149.620 says you pay an administrative fee when you start, and that the Secretary of Health and Human Services sets the amount in guidance. The CMS dispute page, checked on November 14, 2026, says the fee is $25. Use the amount on that page when you file, in case the guidance changes later.

CMS says the $25 fee is non-refundable and that the dispute does not start until it is paid. CMS says that if the dispute is decided in your favor, the $25 is deducted from the amount you owe the provider. The regulation applies that reduction when the reviewer's final amount is lower than the billed charges. CMS also says that, no matter the outcome, your costs will not increase if you dispute the bill.

CMS says you can pay online by credit card, PayPal, or Venmo. If you mail the dispute, CMS says to pay by money order or cashier's check. Cash and personal checks are not accepted.

You and the provider can settle before the reviewer decides. CMS says the provider must then reduce the bill by at least $12.50, which is half of the $25 fee, and must tell the reviewer about the settlement. The regulation describes that reduction as at least half of the administrative fee.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

What to keep and how to start

CMS says to keep the good faith estimate in a safe place and to take a picture of it. When you get the bill, compare it with the estimate. CMS says not to mail original documents.

CMS says you need a digital or paper copy of the good faith estimate, a copy of the bill, the provider's contact information, and the $25 fee. 45 CFR 149.620 says the notice that starts the dispute must also include enough information to identify the item or service, including the date and a description, the state where the care was furnished, and how you want to be contacted. The regulation says you can send the notice through the federal portal, electronically, or on paper, in the way the Secretary specifies. Start from the CMS dispute page so you use the current form.

A letter to the billing office can ask the provider to explain the difference. It does not start this federal process. A letter you can adapt is in free medical bill letter templates.

If the notice is incomplete, or the reviewer finds the item ineligible, 45 CFR 149.620 says you may send the missing information postmarked within 21 calendar days. Keep proof of when you sent it.

  • The good faith estimate for the provider or facility that sent the bill.
  • The bill from that same provider or facility, and the date you received it.
  • The provider's name and contact information, if they are not already on the estimate.
  • Proof of how and when you submitted the dispute and paid the fee.

References: CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance · CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

What the provider cannot do during the dispute

CMS says that while you are disputing the bill, the provider or facility cannot move the bill into collections or threaten to, cannot collect existing late fees until the process ends, and cannot take action against you because you are disputing. CMS says that if the bill is already in collections, the provider or facility must stop pursuing payment until the dispute is resolved.

45 CFR 149.620 applies while the federal dispute is pending. It says the provider must not move the disputed bill into collection or threaten to. If the bill has already moved into collection, the regulation says the provider should cease collection efforts. It says the provider must suspend the accrual of new late fees until the process ends. The CMS page, quoted above, instead says the provider cannot collect late fees that already exist. The regulation also says the provider must not take or threaten retributive action because you used the process. These limits apply to the federal dispute, not to a letter you send on your own.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

What the reviewer decides

CMS says that if you needed items or services the provider could not reasonably have anticipated, the reviewer can find the cost appropriate and leave the bill as it is. CMS says the provider must reduce the bill if the provider should have been able to tell you about those costs in advance, or if the unplanned services and supplies were not medically necessary.

45 CFR 149.620 is more specific, and it does not promise that you will pay only the estimate. For an item that was on the estimate, the billed charge stands if it is not higher than the expected charge. If it is higher, and the provider does not give credible information that the difference was the cost of a medically necessary item or service based on unforeseen circumstances the provider could not reasonably have anticipated, the amount for that item is the expected charge. If the provider does give that information, the regulation uses the lesser of the billed charge or the median amount paid by a plan for the same or similar service by a similar provider in the area, from an independent database, and not less than the expected charge on the estimate.

For a new item that was not on the estimate, the regulation sets the amount at $0 if the provider does not give that credible information. If the provider does, the amount is the lesser of the billed charge or that median amount. The reviewer adds the item amounts. When that total is lower than the billed charges, the regulation says the administrative fee you paid is subtracted to reach what you owe.

The regulation says the decision is binding unless there was fraud or misrepresentation of the facts given to the reviewer. You and the provider can still agree to a different amount, and the provider can agree to charge less or offer financial assistance. Paying the bill before the decision does not, by itself, mean you agreed to that amount.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

If you used insurance instead

CMS says that if you used health insurance, you do not qualify for this dispute. This process is not the way to challenge a deductible, coinsurance, or an insurance denial.

An unexpected out-of-network bill can be a different problem. CMS says the No Surprises Act protects many people with employer coverage, Marketplace coverage, or other individual coverage from certain out-of-network bills for emergency care, for non-emergency care related to a visit at an in-network hospital, hospital outpatient department, or ambulatory surgical center, and for air ambulance services. In the situations it covers, you generally owe your in-network cost sharing. See the No Surprises Act and balance billing.

CMS says a bill you received because you have not met your deductible is not a violation of the No Surprises Act. If the plan denied the claim, use the appeal instructions on the notice. If you did use insurance, the hospital's posted standard charges are a different tool from this estimate. See hospital price transparency.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · CMS: Your medical bill rights when using insurance

If you do not qualify

CMS says that if you did not use insurance and you do not qualify for the dispute, review financial assistance and that you can submit a complaint if the provider did not give you a good faith estimate. Ask the billing office for its financial assistance policy. See hospital charity care. A lower price or a payment plan is a request, not a promise. See how to negotiate a medical bill.

CMS's bill-checking page lists the No Surprises Help Desk at 1-800-985-3059 for questions about the No Surprises Act. If a reviewer decided in your favor and the provider is still billing you, the CMS dispute page says to submit a complaint to that help desk.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · CMS: Check your medical bill for errors

Who can get a good faith estimate?

CMS says you can get one if you do not have health insurance or you are not using it, when you schedule care at least 3 business days ahead or when you ask. CMS says you will not get one during emergency care. Tell the provider before the care that you are not using insurance. 45 CFR 149.610 calls this uninsured or self-pay. That is a person with no benefits for the item or service under a health plan, health insurance, a federal health care program, or a Federal Employees Health Benefits plan, or a person who has benefits under a health plan, health insurance, or a Federal Employees Health Benefits plan but is not asking the provider to submit a claim.

References: CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance · 45 CFR 149.610, Good faith estimates for uninsured or self-pay patients

How much higher does the bill have to be?

At least $400 more than that provider's or facility's good faith estimate. CMS says one provider or facility must have charged at least $400 more than its own estimate. 45 CFR 149.620 defines substantially in excess the same way: that provider's total billed charges are at least $400 above the total expected charges on the good faith estimate for that provider or facility. Do not combine every bill from the visit and compare the total with one estimate.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

How long do I have to start the dispute?

Act within 120 calendar days, and do not wait to see which count is longer. The CMS dispute page says the initial bill must be dated within the last 120 calendar days. The CMS rights page says to start within 120 days of getting the initial bill. 45 CFR 149.620 says the starting notice must be postmarked within 120 calendar days of receiving the initial bill.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · CMS: Medical bill rights when not using insurance · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

What does the dispute cost?

The CMS dispute page says the fee is $25 and that it is non-refundable. The dispute does not start until the fee is paid. If the dispute is decided in your favor, CMS says the $25 is deducted from what you owe the provider. CMS also says your costs will not increase if you dispute the bill. You can pay online by credit card, PayPal, or Venmo. By mail, CMS accepts a money order or a cashier's check, not cash or a personal check. The regulation says the government sets this fee in guidance, so confirm the amount on the CMS page when you file.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · 45 CFR 149.620, Patient-provider dispute resolution

What if I used health insurance?

You do not qualify for this dispute. CMS says the patient-provider dispute process is for people who did not use health insurance. For an unexpected out-of-network bill, read the No Surprises Act and balance billing. CMS says owing a deductible is not a No Surprises Act violation. A denied claim uses your plan's appeal process.

References: CMS: Dispute a bill above a good faith estimate · CMS: Your medical bill rights when using insurance

What this guide cannot promise

This is general information, not legal advice. Your estimate, your bill, and the current CMS dispute page control the steps that apply to you. A dispute can leave the bill unchanged when the higher charge was for care the provider could not reasonably have anticipated. BillHelp cannot promise a lower bill.

Sources and further help

These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.

Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.

Report a broken link or suggest a correction.

← Explore all 141 guides