Emergency Room Bill Too High? Check the Visit Level
How do I know if my emergency room bill is too high?
Start with the visit level. Hospitals and emergency physicians usually bill an ER visit with one of five codes, 99281 through 99285, and the hospital and the physician each choose their own level under different rules. A high level is not automatically wrong. To check it, get the itemized bills, compare them with your explanation of benefits and your medical record, and ask each billing office for a coding review. This page explains how the levels work, what research says, and the deadlines. It does not promise that a charge will change.
Get help with my bill →What do codes 99281 through 99285 mean?
The points below were checked on the American Medical Association's 2023 CPT evaluation and management descriptors and guidelines, on CMS, and on the other sources listed on this page, on November 17, 2026. The AMA says code language can change. The code on your claim and the medical record control your visit. This page does not copy the code descriptors.
The AMA's guidelines use codes 99281, 99282, 99283, 99284, and 99285 to report evaluation and management services in the emergency department. For this purpose, the guidelines define an emergency department as an organized hospital-based facility for unscheduled episodic services to patients who present for immediate medical attention, and they say the facility must be available 24 hours a day. They say these codes do not distinguish a new patient from an established patient.
The same guidelines say time is not a descriptive component for choosing among these emergency department levels. They say the level of medical decision making does not apply to 99281. The guideline describes 99281 as a visit that may not require the presence of a physician or other qualified health care professional. The guidelines tie 99282 to straightforward medical decision making, 99283 to a low level, 99284 to a moderate level, and 99285 to a high level. A higher code is not, by itself, proof that the code is wrong. The record has to support the level.
A 2023 Health Affairs study of emergency claims says almost all emergency visits are billed with codes in this range, with 99285 reserved for the most severe cases. KFF Health News describes each higher level as getting more generous reimbursement, in theory in line with the work required.
Critical care uses different codes, 99291 and, for added time, 99292. KFF Health News reported that under the coding system, critical care is generally defined as a doctor directly providing at least 30 minutes of care to a patient with a probability of imminent or life-threatening deterioration.
References: AMA: 2023 CPT evaluation and management descriptors and guidelines, including emergency department codes 99281-99285 · Health Affairs (August 2023): Price increases versus upcoding as drivers of emergency department spending increases, 2012-19 · KFF Health News (October 27, 2021): How billing turns a routine birth into a high-cost emergency · KFF Health News (April 28, 2026): An urgent care treated her allergic reaction. An ER monitored her, for $6,700
Why are there two ER bills with two different levels?
The hospital and the physician can each send a bill. The hospital usually bills a facility charge for the room, staff, supplies, and equipment, and the emergency physician group often sends a separate professional bill. The Center for Public Integrity reported in 2012 that the hospital facility fee comes on top of physician charges. Ask each billing office which code is on its claim. Do not assume the two bills use the same code for the same reason. How a facility can add its own charge is in a hospital facility fee. Why one visit can produce two statements is in two bills for one hospital visit. Those emergency-department visit levels are not the description of a typical urgent care visit. See an urgent care bill.
The hospital's level comes from its own guidelines. The Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Chapter 4, Section 160, says that while a national set of facility-specific codes and guidelines is awaited, hospitals should keep applying their internal guidelines to the existing CPT codes. It says each hospital's guidelines should reasonably relate the intensity of hospital resources to the different levels of effort the codes represent, and should reflect resource distinctions between the five levels. There is no single national scoring system for the hospital's level.
The physician's level follows the CPT rules above. The American College of Emergency Physicians says that since January 1, 2023, emergency department codes are selected based on medical decision making, and history and exam are no longer elements for choosing the code. Time is used for the critical care codes 99291 and 99292, not for 99281 through 99285.
References: Center for Public Integrity (September 20, 2012): Hospitals grab at least $1 billion in extra fees for emergency room visits · Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Publication 100-04, Chapter 4, Section 160, clinic and emergency visits · American College of Emergency Physicians: 2023 ED E/M guidelines FAQs
Where does the visit level show up on a bill or EOB?
Look for the level in these places.
- Itemized hospital bill: a line such as "ED visit level 4" or "Emergency room, level 5," often with a CPT code such as 99284 or 99285 and a revenue code. If the bill shows one total with no lines, ask for an itemized bill. The next section covers how to ask for one.
- Emergency physician bill: a separate statement from a physician group, with its own code from 99281 to 99285.
- Explanation of benefits: the plan's statement may list the procedure code and the allowed amount for each claim. It is not a bill.
- Critical care: lines with 99291, and sometimes 99292 for added time. In the case KFF Health News reported in April 2026, most of the patient's emergency room charges came from those two codes.
Is a high ER visit level always wrong?
No. A high level can match the care. The research points both ways, and the figures below are dated. None of them says whether your own visit was coded correctly.
- Health Affairs, December 2022: in a national sample of emergency visits where the patient went home, high-intensity billing (99285 or critical care) rose from 4.8 percent of visits in 2006 to 19.2 percent in 2019. The authors estimated that 47 percent of that growth was expected from changes in patient case-mix and services, such as older patients, more health conditions, and more testing.
- Health Affairs, August 2023: in Blue Cross Blue Shield commercial claims from five states, 2012 to 2019, price increases were the largest source of the rise in emergency spending per visit in four of the five states. Upcoding accounted for 30 percent of the per-visit spending increase in Colorado, 23 percent in North Carolina, 16 percent in Texas, and 49 percent in Massachusetts.
- HHS Office of Inspector General, May 2012: physicians' billing of the highest emergency department visit code, 99285, to Medicare rose from 27 percent to 48 percent of those visit services between 2001 and 2010. The report said OIG did not determine whether physicians who billed higher level codes billed inappropriately.
- Center for Public Integrity, September 2012: hospitals' use of the two highest emergency codes rose from 25 percent to 45 percent of Medicare claims for patients sent home from the emergency room, from 2001 to 2008. Hospitals and federal officials said sicker patients and more accurate billing were likely causes. The investigation also reported that hospitals set their own billing policies with little agency guidance and even less auditing.
The 2023 Health Affairs study says future studies should assess whether the 2023 change in how physician levels are chosen alters the rate of upcoding. Ask about your own visit rather than assuming either way.
References: Health Affairs (December 2022): Trends in treat-and-release emergency care visits with high-intensity billing in the US, 2006-19 · Health Affairs (August 2023): Price increases versus upcoding as drivers of emergency department spending increases, 2012-19 · HHS OIG (May 2012): Coding Trends of Medicare Evaluation and Management Services, OEI-04-10-00180 · Center for Public Integrity (September 20, 2012): Hospitals grab at least $1 billion in extra fees for emergency room visits
How can I tell if the ER visit level does not match the care?
You cannot prove a coding error from the bill alone. You can find a reason to ask. These are reasons to ask, not proof.
- The level is 99285 or critical care, and the visit was brief and routine. Level 5 is meant for the most severe cases.
- An emergency charge for care you did not get in the emergency department. KFF Health News reported a Level 5 emergency charge on a routine childbirth bill after the patient was told to enter through the emergency room doors. The hospital's billing office said the charge was for the obstetric triage area.
- The hospital and physician levels are far apart. They can differ for legitimate reasons, because different rules set them, but you can ask each office why.
- Critical care you do not recall. KFF Health News reported in April 2026 on a patient treated for an allergic reaction whose visit was billed with 99291 and 99292. The hospital's audit and appeals department wrote that the critical care designation was based on the presenting problem, the treatment, and the nursing staff, and was not based on time spent. An emergency medicine chair quoted in the story said she was under critical care because of what could have happened, not what did happen.
- The medical record does not show the tests or treatment the bill implies.
- The explanation of benefits or the patient portal shows a different code than the bill.
- A final diagnosis that turned out to be minor is not, by itself, a reason. The American College of Emergency Physicians says the final diagnosis does not determine the complexity, because an extensive evaluation may be needed to rule out a serious condition.
References: Health Affairs (August 2023): Price increases versus upcoding as drivers of emergency department spending increases, 2012-19 · KFF Health News (October 27, 2021): How billing turns a routine birth into a high-cost emergency · KFF Health News (April 28, 2026): An urgent care treated her allergic reaction. An ER monitored her, for $6,700 · American College of Emergency Physicians: 2023 ED E/M guidelines FAQs
How do I get the itemized bill and the record?
CMS says a bill's description of a service can be general, abbreviated, or a code you do not recognize. If you do not understand a line, contact the provider or facility. Ask the hospital billing office for an itemized bill that lists each charge for that visit, including the emergency department code. How to read the lines is in an itemized medical bill review. Ask for the CPT or HCPCS codes, the revenue codes, and the dates of service, and ask the emergency physician group for its own itemized bill. Put the request in writing. State rules on itemized bills differ.
CMS also says to compare the bill with the explanation of benefits and to make sure you were billed for the services you received. The explanation of benefits is the plan's statement. It is not the bill. See how an explanation of benefits differs from a medical bill. If you have Original Medicare, use the Medicare Summary Notice. See how to read a Medicare Summary Notice.
The visit record is a separate request. HHS says the HIPAA Privacy Rule generally requires most providers to give you access, on request, to protected health information about you in a designated record set, which includes medical records and billing records the provider uses to make decisions. HHS says the provider must act no later than 30 calendar days after it receives the request. If it cannot finish in that time, it may take one extension of up to 30 more days, and it must tell you in writing, within the first 30 days, why it needs more time and the date it will finish. HealthIT.gov says you may have to pay for the cost of copying and mailing. The fee limits and a letter you can adapt are in medical records and the claim file. Ask for the record of this emergency visit so the code can be compared with what was documented. Do not ask anyone to describe care you did not receive.
References: CMS: How to read your medical bill · HHS OCR: Individuals' right under HIPAA to access their health information · 45 CFR 164.524, Access of individuals to protected health information · HealthIT.gov: Your health information rights
How do I ask for a coding review?
CMS says to contact the provider or facility if you think there is an error on the bill or the explanation of benefits. Write to the hospital billing or coding office with the account number, the date of the visit, and the code you are asking about. Ask the office to compare that code with the record and to explain, in writing, what in the record supports the level. Ask which internal guideline the hospital used to set its level. Medicare's manual tells hospitals to use internal guidelines, but this page does not cite a rule that requires a hospital to give you its guideline. You do not need to name a replacement code. If a separate physician group billed the visit, send the same question to that office.
A request for review is not a promise that the code will change. The office does not have to replace a code that matches the record. Do not ask anyone to report a lower level than the record supports. The general steps for a coding question are in how to fix a medical claim coding error. If the office agrees the code was wrong, ask when it will send a corrected claim, and ask it to pause collection on the disputed amount while the plan reprocesses the claim. A pause is not automatic.
Keep a log of each call: the date, the person's name, and what they said. Follow up in writing. Do not ignore collection letters.
Hi, I'm calling about my emergency room visit on [date], account [number]. Please send an itemized bill with the CPT or HCPCS codes, revenue codes, and the ER visit level for each charge. I would like the ER visit level reviewed against my medical record. Which level was billed, what guideline does the hospital use to set it, and what in my record supports it? If the level was wrong, please send a corrected bill. Please hold the account while the review is open.
References: CMS: How to read your medical bill · Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Publication 100-04, Chapter 4, Section 160, clinic and emergency visits
How do I dispute the claim with the plan?
If the plan paid based on a code you believe is wrong, or it denied the visit, use the plan's appeal as well as the provider review. The denial notice or the explanation of benefits should say how to appeal and the deadline. HealthCare.gov explains internal appeals for the plans those rules cover. A correction request to the hospital may not extend that deadline, so keep both clocks. See how to appeal a health insurance denial.
Ask member services which code and allowed amount the plan received, and whether it will review the claim. KFF Health News advises coming to the phone with an itemized bill, medical records, and documents such as explanation-of-benefits statements when you dispute charges with the plan and the hospital.
In a case KFF Health News reported in May 2020, the insurer reprocessed a patient's emergency claims and waived his cost sharing after KFF Health News asked it to review the case. That was a COVID billing-code issue, not a visit-level issue. Outcomes vary.
An accurately coded visit can still leave you with a deductible or coinsurance. That amount is not a coding error. An emergency room bill the plan did not cover for a different reason is in an emergency room bill insurance did not cover.
If Original Medicare was billed for a service you did not receive, Medicare.gov says to call the provider if a charge looks incorrect, and to call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) if you suspect fraud. A level you disagree with is first a coding review. It is not, by itself, a fraud report. See how to read a Medicare Summary Notice.
References: HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · KFF Health News (April 28, 2026): An urgent care treated her allergic reaction. An ER monitored her, for $6,700 · KFF Health News (May 25, 2020): COVID-like cough sent him to the ER, where he got a $3,278 bill · CMS: How to read your medical bill · Medicare.gov: Reporting Medicare fraud and abuse
What deadlines apply to an ER bill dispute?
Check every notice for its own deadline.
- Plan appeal of a denial: HealthCare.gov says you must file an internal appeal within 180 days (6 months) of receiving notice that your claim was denied.
- Medical record request: the provider has 30 days to act, with one extension of up to 30 more days, as described above.
- The federal patient-provider dispute process does not fit most insured ER bills. CMS says you can use it only if you did not have or did not use health insurance for the care, you had a good faith estimate, your initial bill is dated within the last 120 calendar days, and a provider or facility charged at least $400 more than its estimate. CMS also says a bill you get because you have not met your deductible is not a No Surprises Act violation.
- An out-of-network emergency bill is a different problem. CMS says the No Surprises Act protects you from unexpected out-of-network bills for emergency room visits. The No Surprises Help Desk is 1-800-985-3059. See what the No Surprises Act covers.
References: HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · CMS: Patient-provider dispute eligibility · CMS: No Surprises Act help for consumers
What if the hospital will not change the ER visit level?
Ask for the result in writing. You can ask for a supervisor, the patient advocate, or the compliance office. If the plan is the problem, your state insurance department takes complaints, and the NAIC lists each state's department. If the balance is correct but you cannot afford it, ask about financial assistance and a payment plan. See what to do when a medical bill is too high and how to negotiate a medical bill. If you already paid, you can still ask for a review. Whether a refund is possible depends on the provider, the plan, and your state. See a medical bill overpayment refund.
Results vary. KFF Health News reported in November 2021 on a patient billed for a Level 4 emergency visit for six stitches and a tetanus shot. He and his wife asked the hospital and the physicians' group to review the charges, and both were sticking by the original bills when the story ran. In the 2021 childbirth case, the patient eventually paid the bill, and KFF Health News reported that at least one other patient got the emergency charge removed after hours on the phone.
References: NAIC: State insurance departments and how to file a complaint · KFF Health News (November 19, 2021): The ER charged him $6,500 for six stitches · KFF Health News (October 27, 2021): How billing turns a routine birth into a high-cost emergency
What this page cannot promise
This is general information, not medical or legal advice. A higher code can be the correct code for the visit. A coding review can confirm the original code. An appeal can be denied. Nothing on this page says how often an emergency visit is coded too high, and nothing here promises that a hospital or a plan will lower the charge. The research figures on this page are national and dated, and they do not say whether your visit was coded correctly.
Sources and further help
These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.
- AMA: 2023 CPT evaluation and management descriptors and guidelines, including emergency department codes 99281-99285 ↗
- CMS: How to read your medical bill ↗
- HHS OCR: Individuals' right under HIPAA to access their health information ↗
- 45 CFR 164.524, Access of individuals to protected health information ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals ↗
- Medicare.gov: Reporting Medicare fraud and abuse ↗
- Health Affairs (August 2023): Price increases versus upcoding as drivers of emergency department spending increases, 2012-19 ↗
- Health Affairs (December 2022): Trends in treat-and-release emergency care visits with high-intensity billing in the US, 2006-19 ↗
- HHS OIG (May 2012): Coding Trends of Medicare Evaluation and Management Services, OEI-04-10-00180 ↗
- Center for Public Integrity (September 20, 2012): Hospitals grab at least $1 billion in extra fees for emergency room visits ↗
- Medicare Claims Processing Manual, Publication 100-04, Chapter 4, Section 160, clinic and emergency visits ↗
- American College of Emergency Physicians: 2023 ED E/M guidelines FAQs ↗
- KFF Health News (April 28, 2026): An urgent care treated her allergic reaction. An ER monitored her, for $6,700 ↗
- KFF Health News (October 27, 2021): How billing turns a routine birth into a high-cost emergency ↗
- KFF Health News (May 25, 2020): COVID-like cough sent him to the ER, where he got a $3,278 bill ↗
- KFF Health News (November 19, 2021): The ER charged him $6,500 for six stitches ↗
- HealthIT.gov: Your health information rights ↗
- CMS: Patient-provider dispute eligibility ↗
- CMS: No Surprises Act help for consumers ↗
- NAIC: State insurance departments and how to file a complaint ↗
Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.