Screening Colonoscopy Billed After Polyps or a Stool Test
What can I do if a screening colonoscopy was billed after polyps were removed or a stool test was positive?
A screening colonoscopy is not automatically free once a polyp is removed, and the answer depends on your coverage. Many non-grandfathered private plans are not allowed to impose cost sharing for polyp removal during a screening, or for a follow-up colonoscopy after a positive stool test, when the rest of the preventive rule applies. Medicare.gov says you pay nothing for the screening if the provider accepts assignment, and 15 percent if a polyp or other tissue is removed. This page explains what to ask, and it does not promise the charge will be removed.
Get help with my bill →Start with which colonoscopy this was
The points below were checked on the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force site, HealthCare.gov, the Departments' FAQ Part 51 and FAQ Part 68, eCFR, and Medicare.gov on November 17, 2026. Your explanation of benefits, or your Medicare Summary Notice, is the decision to answer.
Three different bills get mixed together. One is a colonoscopy scheduled as screening, during which a polyp or other tissue was removed. One is a colonoscopy done because a stool test, a flexible sigmoidoscopy, or a CT colonography was positive or abnormal. One is a colonoscopy ordered to look into a symptom, such as bleeding or pain. The first two can be part of screening. The third is a different question. The broader preventive rule is in a bill for preventive care.
Ask for the itemized statement and the explanation of benefits before you pay. How to request the statement is in how to request an itemized medical bill. How the two documents differ is in an explanation of benefits versus a medical bill. An upper endoscopy is not a colonoscopy. If the denial or the bill is for an upper endoscopy, see an endoscopy denial.
Does removing a polyp make a screening colonoscopy a bill?
For the private plans this rule covers, polyp removal during a screening colonoscopy is not, by itself, a reason to add cost sharing. FAQ Part 51, issued January 10, 2022, says that if a colonoscopy is scheduled and performed as a screening procedure under the Task Force recommendation, cost sharing may not be imposed for items and services that are an integral part of performing it. The FAQ lists a required specialist consultation before the screening, bowel-preparation medications prescribed for it, anesthesia in connection with a preventive colonoscopy, polyp removal during the screening procedure, and a pathology exam on a polyp biopsy performed as part of the screening.
FAQ Part 68, issued October 21, 2024, gives an example. An in-network provider removes a polyp during a routine preventive colonoscopy and submits the claim with modifier 33 and a screening diagnosis, using coding the FAQ calls industry-standard. The plan treats the colonoscopy as therapeutic and imposes cost sharing. The FAQ says the plan had no individualized information that the colonoscopy was not a screening. The FAQ's conclusion is that imposing cost sharing in that situation violates the preventive-services rule, and that the plan should process the claim as a recommended preventive service without cost sharing.
That example is not a code you have to name. Ask the billing office whether the claim identified the colonoscopy as screening, including any screening diagnosis or modifier 33, and whether the record shows the colonoscopy was scheduled as screening. Ask the office to compare the claim with the record. If the coding does not match the record, ask it to send a corrected claim. Do not ask anyone to label a symptom-based colonoscopy as screening so the plan will pay. How to ask is in how to fix a medical claim coding error.
A colonoscopy ordered to evaluate symptoms is outside that screening example. 45 CFR 147.130 says a plan may impose cost sharing for a treatment that is not a recommended preventive service, even if the treatment results from one. A separate anesthesia or pathology bill can still be part of the screening the FAQ describes. A separate clinician you did not meet is explained in a bill from a doctor you never saw. A hospital outpatient department can also add its own charge. See a hospital facility fee.
References: DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 51, including colonoscopy coverage · DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 68, preventive coding and appeals · 45 CFR 147.130, Coverage of preventive health services
Is a colonoscopy after a positive stool test still screening?
Often yes, for the people and plans the rule covers. The Task Force recommendation of May 18, 2021 gives an A grade to screening all adults aged 50 to 75, and a B grade to screening adults aged 45 to 49. It gives a C grade to selectively offering screening to adults aged 76 to 85. The recommendation says it applies to asymptomatic adults 45 and older who are at average risk. It says that when stool-based tests reveal abnormal results, follow-up with colonoscopy is needed for further evaluation, and that positive results on stool-based screening tests require follow-up with colonoscopy for the screening benefits to be achieved. It says abnormal findings on flexible sigmoidoscopy or CT colonography also require follow-up colonoscopy for those benefits to be achieved.
FAQ Part 51 says a plan or issuer must cover, and may not impose cost sharing for, a colonoscopy conducted after a positive non-invasive stool-based screening test or a direct visualization screening test, such as a sigmoidoscopy or CT colonography, for individuals described in the Task Force recommendation. The FAQ says that follow-up colonoscopy is an integral part of the preventive screening, without which the screening would not be complete. It says plans and issuers must provide that coverage for plan or policy years beginning on or after May 31, 2022. HealthCare.gov's adult preventive list includes colorectal cancer screening for adults 45 to 75.
The A and B grades are the grades 45 CFR 147.130 uses for the no-cost preventive rule. The C grade, for ages 76 to 85, is not that A or B requirement. This page does not turn a selective offer of screening into a no-cost guarantee. A grandfathered plan is outside the no-cost rule the departments state for non-grandfathered plans. 45 CFR 147.130 also says a plan with a network does not have to cover an out-of-network preventive service, and it may impose cost sharing for it, unless the plan has no in-network provider who can provide the service. Ask the plan which of these limits it applied.
References: U.S. Preventive Services Task Force: colorectal cancer screening, May 18, 2021 · DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 51, including colonoscopy coverage · HealthCare.gov: Adult preventive benefits and limits · 45 CFR 147.130, Coverage of preventive health services · 45 CFR 147.140: Grandfathered health plans, including the clinical-trial exception · HealthCare.gov: Preventive health services
What does Medicare charge if a polyp is removed?
Original Medicare does not use the private-plan FAQ. Medicare.gov says Part B covers screening colonoscopies, with no minimum age. If your doctor or other health care provider accepts assignment, Medicare.gov says you pay nothing for the screening test, including a follow-up colonoscopy after a positive result from a Medicare-covered non-invasive stool-based test or a blood-based biomarker screening test.
Medicare's polyp rule is different from the private-plan rule. Medicare.gov says that if the provider finds and removes a polyp or other tissue during the colonoscopy, you pay 15 percent of the Medicare-approved amount for the provider's services. In a hospital outpatient setting or an ambulatory surgical center, you also pay the facility a 15 percent coinsurance. Medicare.gov says the Part B deductible does not apply. Other insurance you have can change what you pay. This page does not state a dollar amount.
How often also matters. Medicare.gov says the screening is covered once every 24 months if you are at high risk for colorectal cancer. If you are not at high risk, it says Part B covers the test once every 120 months, or 48 months after a previous flexible sigmoidoscopy. Medicare.gov says a doctor may recommend a service Medicare does not cover, or covers less often, and that can mean additional cost. Ask which interval Medicare applied. This page does not define high risk.
If Original Medicare denies the claim or you disagree with the amount, start with the Medicare Summary Notice. See how to read a Medicare Summary Notice and how to appeal an Original Medicare denial. A Medicare Advantage plan uses its own appeal. See how to appeal a Medicare Advantage denial.
References: Medicare.gov: Screening colonoscopies
What should I ask, and when do I appeal?
Ask the billing office, in writing, whether the colonoscopy was scheduled as screening or to evaluate a symptom, and whether a polyp was removed. Ask for the claim lines, including any screening diagnosis or modifier 33 the office submitted. You do not need to propose a replacement code. A corrected claim is a request to the office. It is not the plan's appeal, and the office does not have to change a code that matches the record.
If the claim already identifies the service as a recommended preventive service and the plan still imposes cost sharing, appeal the plan's decision. FAQ Part 68 says that when an in-network claim uses industry-standard coding to identify a recommended preventive service, the plan should cover it without cost sharing unless the plan has individualized information that the service was not that preventive service for you. It also says that if the plan makes an adverse benefit determination, you can appeal under the internal-appeal and external-review rules that apply to your plan. How to file is in how to appeal a health insurance denial. Whether an outside review is available is in how to request an external review. The notice has the deadline.
Use the questions below. Keep the answers with the explanation of benefits.
- Was this colonoscopy scheduled as screening, or was it ordered because of a symptom?
- Was it a follow-up after a positive stool test, sigmoidoscopy, or CT colonography?
- Did the claim identify the service as screening, and did the plan say it had information that it was not?
- For Medicare, did the provider accept assignment, was a polyp removed, and which screening interval did Medicare apply?
- Is this a request for a corrected claim, or an appeal of the plan's payment decision?
References: DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 68, preventive coding and appeals · HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals · HealthCare.gov: External review
What this page cannot promise
This is general information, not medical or legal advice. A symptom-based colonoscopy, a grandfathered plan, an out-of-network colonoscopy when an in-network provider was available, and a Medicare screening in which a polyp was removed can each produce a charge these rules do not erase. Medicare's 15 percent share is Medicare.gov's current description of that polyp removal, not a private-plan copay. An appeal can be denied. Nothing on this page promises that a plan or a billing office will remove the charge.
Sources and further help
These sources provide general guidance. For a deadline or requirement that applies to you, follow your plan’s notice or the appropriate program’s current instructions.
- U.S. Preventive Services Task Force: colorectal cancer screening, May 18, 2021 ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Adult preventive benefits and limits ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Preventive health services ↗
- DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 51, including colonoscopy coverage ↗
- DOL, HHS, and Treasury: ACA FAQ Part 68, preventive coding and appeals ↗
- 45 CFR 147.130, Coverage of preventive health services ↗
- 45 CFR 147.140: Grandfathered health plans, including the clinical-trial exception ↗
- Medicare.gov: Screening colonoscopies ↗
- HealthCare.gov: Internal appeals ↗
- HealthCare.gov: External review ↗
Insurer websites may ask you to select your state or sign in. If a page will not open, use the member services number on your insurance card and ask for the current appeal instructions for your plan.